1. Defendant D and E shall jointly:

A. From May 23, 2008 to Plaintiff A, Defendant D, from May 23, 2008, with respect to KRW 70 million and its amount, March 2015.

1. Basic facts

A. The Defendants’ status and relationship 1) SH Corporation shall be the I Urban Development Project (hereinafter “instant project”) in Songpa-gu Seoul, Songpa-gu Seoul.

In connection with this, the vinyls and sponsing facilities in the instant project site (hereinafter referred to as “sponsing facilities”) were implemented.

(2) Defendant D was a person who purchased a vinyl, a punishment, etc. in the instant project site and sold to a person who wishes to be supplied with a commercial accession or a commercial building site as a compensation for relocation measures, and Defendant E is an employee of Defendant D, and Defendant F and G are employees of the real estate intermediary in the trade name of “J Licensed Real Estate Agent Office”.

3) Defendant F and G heard that Defendant E would offer a recommendation fee of KRW 10,000,000 for each investor, if Defendant E wants to invite people to make investments in a punishment, and introduced investors to Defendant D and E to make investments in a punishment. On that occasion, Defendant E, upon Defendant D’s instruction, has traded a punishment through a method of brying to investors with brying materials created by Defendant D and with brying to investors. (b) Plaintiff F and Defendant D’s wife K met with Defendant F and G via L, respectively.

On May 15, 2008, Plaintiff A purchased 22 copies in the instant project site from Defendant D on May 15, 2008 under the name of Defendant D for the purpose of being supplied with commercial land ownership, etc. as compensation for relocation measures, and paid 10 million won the down payment to Defendant D on the same day, and 70 million won the remainder on May 23, 2008.

On the other hand, Defendant E signed the above punishment sales contract as a observer.

2) Through Plaintiff B’s land, the explanation on the instant project is sought through Defendant E, F, and G, and the Defendant E and F, together with Defendant D’s office, purchase at least KRW 80 million from Defendant D and E again.