Text
1. The judgment of the first instance, including the Plaintiffs’ incidental appeal, is modified as follows.
The Defendants are jointly and severally.
Reasons
1. Basic facts
A. The position of the parties concerned 1) Defendant C (project owner of the removal of this case), Defendant D (project owner of the removal of this case), Defendant C Co., Ltd (hereinafter “Defendant C”)
Defendant D Co., Ltd (hereinafter “Defendant D”) on March 26, 2016
2) L building (hereinafter referred to as “instant building”) is called L building
3) Of G construction, the removal works (hereinafter “instant removal works”) refer to the removal works
B) A contract was made between Defendant C and Defendant D’s representative director, and N are Defendant D’s representative director. 2) Defendant F and E (operator of the instant accusation work) Defendant F are the I accusation work vehicle (hereinafter “instant accusation work vehicle”).
A) The owner of the instant complaint (Evidence 8). Defendant E, the husband of Defendant F, is working using the instant complaint vehicle at the construction site (No. 4-1). Defendant E lent the instant complaint vehicle to Defendant D on March 27, 2016, and then had the relevant workersJ work using the instant complaint vehicle at the site of the removal construction site.
(B) On March 27, 2016, K (victim 6) had been engaged in the work using the instant vehicle at the site of the removal construction of the instant case and died as a fall accident (Evidence 4-1). (B) On March 27, 2016, K received N’s instructions from N, and around March 27, 2016, at around 09:45, K carried out the work of carrying the construction waste of the 7th floor of the instant building at the height of 29 meters, which is located in the instant complaint construction vehicle (hereinafter “instant complaint construction vehicle”).
2 K, with the wind to load construction waste exceeding 300 km in a maximum loading capacity of 2,500 km, was crashed with K for the accusation work of this case, which did not have a weighted with K for the accusation work of this case, and K for this reason fell with the third floor of the building of this case, and K for the accusation work of this case.