1. The instant lawsuit shall be dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

According to the evidence Nos. 1-1 to 3-3, it is recognized that the defendant was confirmed to be granted a decision to grant a bankruptcy decision (the Busan District Court Decision 2010Hadan669, 2010Ma669, 669). The claims of this case claimed by the plaintiff constitute bankruptcy claims arising before the bankruptcy declaration was declared, and there is no evidence to deem that the defendant had omitted the plaintiff's claims in bad faith due to the bankruptcy and exemption procedures. Thus, the defendant was exempted from the responsibility to pay the debts of this case due to

Therefore, since the lawsuit of this case is unlawful because there is no benefit of protecting the rights, it is so decided as per Disposition.