1. Defendant G in excess of the part against Defendant A from among the judgment of the first instance, and the amount ordered to be paid below.

1. Basic facts

A. The sales process of the right to preferential benefit with respect to the apartment of this case 1) L organization (hereinafter “L”).

M Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “M”) as a special purpose corporation

2) The apartment complex of this case (hereinafter referred to as the “instant apartment”) is established by the establishment of the Dongwon-si and located in one source, such as the N in Suwon-si.

2) In order to newly construct and sell the apartment in this case, 124 households among the total apartment units in this case left unsold in lots, etc., and as a result, it was difficult for M to repay the PF loans. On December 23, 2010, M entered into a management-type land trust contract on the instant apartment site (NL and six parcels outside the city of orchard) and the management-type land trust contract on the instant apartment site (NL and six parcels outside the city of orchard). Accordingly, L was jointly and severally liable as the assignee of the debt, and thus, L was jointly and severally entitled to a second priority right, third priority right, and other rights incidental thereto.

3) L는 매각공고에 따른 입찰을 거쳐 2013. 1. 24.경 주식회사 깜(이하 ‘깜’이라 한다

)에게 270억 원에 위 아파트에 대한 3순위 우선수익권 등 일체의 권리를 양도하였다. 4) M, 무궁화신탁, 깜은 2013. 4. 5. M은 위탁자로서, 무궁화신탁은 수탁자로서, 깜은 수익자로서 이 사건 아파트 중 미분양된 125세대에 관하여 ‘부동산담보신탁계약’을 체결하고, 깜은 2013. 4. 20.부터 이 사건 아파트에 대한 미분양분에 대한 분양대금을 무궁화신탁이 지정한 계좌에 입금하는 방법으로 분양절차를 진행하였다.

B. E Co., Ltd., Ltd., 1) E (hereinafter “E”)

(A) On April 12, 2013, a P Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “P”) asserts that all 204 households of the instant apartment were purchased from L. (hereinafter “P”).

P was in the position of the head of Q business on December 6, 2012 and concluded a sales contract with R in the name of the seller to purchase the apartment of this case under the name of the seller and R in the position of the head of Q business.

2) From 200 households of the instant apartment.