The judgment of the court below is reversed.

[Defendant A] Defendant A is punished by imprisonment with prison labor for three years.

evidence of seizure.

1. The Defendants asserted that the summary of the grounds for appeal by both parties are unfair due to the excessive neglect of each of the punishments (four years of imprisonment, one year and six months of imprisonment, and one year and six months of imprisonment) declared by the court below, while the prosecutor asserts that the respective sentences of the court below are too unhued and unfair.

2. In light of the contents, methods, results, etc. of the crime committed by the Defendants in collusion and organized against many and unspecified general public, the crime of telephone finance fraud of this case is considerably serious in nature of the crime; in particular, it is necessary to severely punish the participants because of considerable social damage caused by the rapid increase in organized crimes organized by foreigners, and thus, it is necessary to seriously punish the Defendants in light of the records and arguments; there is no particular criminal history that the Defendants have been punished in the Republic of Korea; there seems to be no possibility that the Defendants would be forced to leave under the Immigration Control Act; Defendant C’s family members want to be forced to leave the Republic of Korea; Defendant C’s family members wished to leave the Republic of Korea; Defendant C’s family members; Defendant C’s family relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation between the victim and the victim; Defendant C’s motive and frequency of participation in the crime; Defendant C’s relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation relation between the victim and the victim; Defendant C’s motive and frequency of participation in the crime.