The defendant's appeal is dismissed.

Expenses for appeal shall be borne by the defendant.

Purport of claim and appeal

1. Purport of the claim.

1. The reasons for this decision are as follows: ① in the 8th judgment of the first instance court, the Plaintiff’s “Plaintiff” in the 8th judgment of the first instance court is dismissed as “Plaintiff”; ② in the 6th part of the 10th part of the 10th part, the “after being known” is added to the right side of the “after being known”; ③ even in the 10th part of the 8th part of the 10th part, the “I can see “Is yous yous yous yous” is described differently in the location or name of yous and the second part of the 8th part of the 10th part of the 10th part of the 10th part. However, it is somewhat different in the year they are sent to yous, except that it is highly likely to cause memory errors due to an interpretation or translation or due to a passage of time,” and it is identical with the entry of the reasons for the first part in the 10th part of the 10 part part.

(1) The defendant's argument at the trial is not significantly different from the argument at the trial of the first instance, and even after re-examination of the evidence submitted at the trial of the first instance and the trial of the first instance, the defendant's argument is rejected and the judgment at the first instance that recognized the plaintiff as a refugee is justifiable). 2. As such, the judgment at the first instance is justifiable, and the defendant's appeal is dismissed as it is without merit. It is