1. The judgment of the court of first instance is modified as follows.

Defendant C, D, E, F, H, K, and L are jointly with the co-defendant G of the first instance trial and the J.

1. Basic facts

A. (1) Plaintiff A is a student who was enrolled in the second grade in the U.S. located in Daejeon-gu around 201, and Plaintiff B is the mother of Plaintiff A. 2) Defendants and the co-defendants of the first instance court are parents of students related to the instant harmful act, as seen below.

The relationship between the Defendants and the students related thereto is as listed in the following [Attachment 1]:

Co-Defendant 1 C, Defendant 1 C, Defendant J 10, Defendant J 2D 2 D D 2, Defendant 2 D D 11, Defendant 7 Defendant 3 and Defendant 3, Defendant 4 Defendant 4 Defendant 4 and Defendant 4 Defendant 4 F 3, Defendant 131, Co-Defendant 51, Co-Defendant 51, Defendant G mother AAA 14, Co-Defendant P 6 Defendant QAB AB 15, Defendant QA 7, Defendant QA 7, Defendant AB 15, Co-Defendant 16, Defendant QA 7, Co-Defendant 8, Defendant RD 171, Co-Defendant 9, Defendant AE 171, Non-Defendant 18, Defendant 18, Co-Defendant 1, Defendant 18, Co-Defendant 1, Defendant 1 and the Defendant 18.

B. 1) The Defendants’ children, V, AB, and X (hereinafter “instant aggressor students”)

[Attachment 1] The students listed in [Attachment 1], together with AF, AG, etc., were subject to investigation or investigation on suspicion of assaulting or inflicting bodily injury on A, as shown in the separate facts constituting a crime (hereinafter collectively referred to as “the instant harmful act” in total, and individually referred to as “the instant harmful act” in the order of each paragraph.

Meanwhile, the plaintiffs' claim for damages against AF, AG and their parents are pending in Daejeon High Court Decision 2016Na15899.

(2) Of the above investigation or investigation results, the aggressor students of this case, AA, and W 6 among the students listed in Table 1 [Attachment 1] were subject to a protective disposition by the Daejeon Family Court as shown below [Attachment 2] on the crime in the attached Form 2.

(hereinafter “instant protective disposition”. On March 5, 2013, 2013, the content of the disposition date of the name and case number disposition date, including V 2012 Pu3458, etc., the guardian entrusted with care and custody, attending lectures, short-term probation, etc. on March 5, 2013.