1.(a)

For the plaintiffs (appointed parties) and the appointed parties, the 1st, Defendant C, Defendant D, and Defendant E respectively are 2,456,320 won and 2,456,320 won.

1. Basic facts

A. The status of the parties 1) Plaintiff (Appointed Party), Appointed M, N, andO, and the rest of the designated parties, excluding M, N, andO, together with “Plaintiffs” for convenience

(2) From February 29, 2008 to September 18, 2008, S Co., Ltd retired on the date indicated in the “Retirement Day” column between the annexed Table 3 attached hereto. (2) At the time when the Plaintiffs retired from S Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant Co., Ltd”) at the time of their retirement from their respective retirement dates except for Defendant 1 through 44, 48 through 159, and Defendant 45 through 47’s ancestor Qu, and their ancestor net 160 through 163’s retirement date. Defendant 164 to 168, at the time of their retirement from their respective retirement dates, at the time of their retirement from their respective above Defendant Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant Co., Ltd.”). Defendant 169 to 171, at the time of their retirement from their respective retirement dates, the remaining Plaintiffs, except for Defendant 17 to 17, YY, excluding Defendant TM’s remaining Defendants at their retirement dates from their respective above Defendant Co.

B. At the time when the Plaintiffs were working for the Defendant Company, the Defendant Union enacted the Welfare Regulations for Workers’ Self-Managed Enterprises (hereinafter “instant Welfare Regulations”) on September 20, 2007, and among them, the details relating to the advance payment and the members’ assistant payment are as follows:

Article 1 (Purpose) The provisions of this Regulation shall encourage the unity and morale of the S Union members, promote their desire to work, and divide them into spirit of mutual assistance.