1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the plaintiff A/D that orders payment below shall be revoked.

Defendant.

1. Basic facts

A. The relevant facts and the Plaintiffs are the buyers who purchased the head office of the Gyeyang-gu Incheon Metropolitan City H, J, K, and L ground I building newly constructed by Defendant E (hereinafter “Defendant E”).

Defendant F is a representative director of Defendant E and a joint and several surety for Defendant E’s debt, and Defendant G is a joint and several surety for Defendant E’s debt.

Unlike the scheduled completion, I building was delayed, and this case is seeking the payment of liquidated damages agreed upon by the plaintiffs according to the delay in completion.

나. 원고 A의 분양계약과 지체상금 약정 분양 계약일 분양 대상 분양대금 지급한 분양대금(관련 증거) 1차 계약 2009. 3.18. 145호, 146호, 147호, 148호, 149호, 153호 2,200,000,000원 2009. 3. 18. 계약금 30,000,000원(갑1-5) 2009. 3. 25. 계약금 및 1차 중도금 570,000,000원(갑1-6) 2009. 8. 7. 2차 중도금 300,000,000원(갑1-9) 2009. 9. 9. 중도금 350,000,000원(갑1-10) 2009. 9. 29. 잔금 300,000,000원(갑1-11) 2009. 9. 29. 잔금 495,000,000원(갑1-12) 2010. 3. 5. 잔금 100,000,000원(갑1-15) 합계 2,145,000,000원 2차 계약 2009. 6.19. 125호, 126호, 127호, 128호 1,400,000,000원 2009. 6. 19. 계약금 100,000,000원(갑1-7) 2009. 6. 25. 중도금 200,000,000원(갑1-8) 2009. 10. 29. 중도금 150,000,000원(갑1-13) 2009. 11. 4. 중도금 150,000,000원(갑1-14) 2010. 10. 26. 잔금 37,500,000원(갑1-18) 합계 637,500,000원 3차 계약 2010. 4.15. 124호, 152호 750,000,000원 2010. 4. 15. 계약금 500,000,000원(갑1-16) 2010. 7. 29. 잔금 110,000,000원(갑1-17) 2010. 12. 23. 잔금 15,000,000원(갑1-19) 합계 625,000,000원 지급한 분양대금 합계 3,407,500,000원 (1) 원고 A은 다음과 같이 피고 E과 3회 분양계약을 체결하고 분양대금을 지급하였다.

(2) The date of completion of the Plaintiff A’s primary contract dated March 18, 2009 shall be determined on June 30, 2009, and the sale price already paid when the completion is delayed for at least 45 days.