1. All appeals filed by the plaintiff and the defendant are dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by each party.

The purport of the claim and appeal is the purport of the appeal.

Facts of recognition

The Plaintiff and the Defendant’s position (the trade name of the Plaintiff and the Defendant (hereinafter “Co., Ltd.”) were “Non-Seiju Shipbuilding”) on November 1, 2002, which was changed in sequence to “Non-Seong-Seong Ho-Sei, Co., Ltd.’s Non-Seong-Sei, Co., Ltd.’ on May 6, 201,” and on September 5, 2011, the company engaged in the comprehensive leisure and sports business and its related business. The Plaintiff acquired three membership units (hereinafter “each of the instant golf clubs”) of Non-Seng-Seng, the golf club operated by the Defendant at No. 43-15 (hereinafter “instant golf club”).

Article 4 (Members) of the major contents of the golf club rules of this case are as follows.

1. An honorary member;

2. Regular members (individual and juristic person);

3. Additional members;

4. Associate members;

5.The other regular members of Article 6 (Regular Members) shall be individual and corporate members, who shall be bound to join the prescribed club and shall obtain the approval of the defendant.

Article 10 (Application for Membership) Any person who intends to become a regular member of any these club shall obtain the approval of the defendant by following the prescribed procedures.

Article 11 (Period of Contract) The period of membership rights shall be the member himself/herself's life from the first date of commencement of membership in cases where the membership fee is paid in full or the payment procedure is completed.

Article 12 (Admission Fees) Membership fees shall be deposited by the defendant as a membership deposit with no interest for five years from the date of registration, and shall be refunded only to the principal in the case of retirement, expulsion, death (in the case of absence of succession), or dissolution of a corporation.

Provided, That in cases of force majeure such as natural disasters, the return may be suspended for a certain period of time according to the resolution of the board of directors.

In addition, in the case of a withdrawal or expulsion, the principal can be returned after the lapse of five years from the date of entry.

Article 13 (Approval for Entrance)

1. Upon receipt of an application for membership, the defendant shall approve the membership within the extent determined by the prescribed standards and review procedures; and

2. The defendant.