1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

(b) there has been no symptoms that may cause serious fluorial color, nor there has been no disease diagnosed by that disease;

Since chronic pulmonary pulmonary diseases occurred to the deceased, the disease was the most directly contributed to the death of the pneumoconiosis, and even if the death was caused by cardiopulmonary color, it is a result of combined action with the pneumoconiosis, so there is a proximate causal relation between the death and the pneumoconiosis of the deceased.

Facts of recognition

망인의 진폐정밀진단이력 등 진단일자 구분 정밀진단기간 정밀진단의료기관 병형 합병증 심폐기능 심의결과 판정결과 장해 등급 1992. 2. 13. 산재 1992. 1. 6. ~1992. 1. 11. F병원 1/0 1997. 11. 10. 산재 1998. 2. 9. ~1998. 2. 14. F병원 3/2 F0† 장해 11급9호 2002. 2. 7. 이직자 2002. 4. 8. ~2002. 4. 13. F병원 3/2 pt ax F0 장해 11급9호 2003. 12. 8. 이직자 2004. 1. 26. ~2004. 1. 31. F병원 4A F0 장해 11급9호 2005. 12. 19. 진폐 (응급) 2005. 12. 19. ~2005. 12. 24. F병원 4A tba* 요양 망인의 병력 망인은 2005. 12. 19. 진폐증으로 요양하기 시작한 이후 한동안 백선 등 피부질환으로 치료를 받았을 뿐 심폐질환으로 치료를 받은 적은 없었다.

From June 2008 to August 201, 201, the Deceased was treated as a detailed informed cata, and from May 201, the Deceased was treated as a type of catacy, which was not accompanied by a complication.

On December 2005, the Deceased started hospital of the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Service with respect to pneumoconiosis and pulmonary tuberculosis after the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis.

On March 15, 2006, the Deceased had been hospitalized again due to the aggravation of the pulmonary difficulty rate on August 11, 2009.

In the Korea Workers' Compensation & Welfare Hospital where the deceased was hospitalized, the deceased performed the pulmonary function test, the chest X-ray test, the dynamic gas test, the heart test, the guest wall test, and the blood science test.