Text
1. The plaintiffs' claims against the defendants are all dismissed.
2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.
Reasons
1. Facts of recognition;
A. The defendants P is the defendants' status 1) The "land parcel number" stated in the annexed contract list in the "land purchase" column in the annexed contract list is the Gyeonggi P, Pyeongtaek-gun T and 11 lots (hereinafter "each land of this case").
2) The U.S. Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “U”) concluded a sales agency contract with Defendant P on each of the instant lands with the company operating real estate sales, lease, etc., and at the time, Defendant Q Q is the representative director and Defendant R was in charge of the sales agency business of each of the instant lands while serving as an employee.
3) Around August 20, 2009, Defendant S was an attorney at the V law office (former Law Office W) and was delegated by Defendant P with the management of the purchase price, cancellation of limited real rights, registration of ownership transfer, and application for partition of co-owned property with respect to each of the instant land. (B) The Plaintiffs were aware of each of the instant land after reporting the sales advertisement of placards and daily newspapers around August 2009 or around September 2009. The Plaintiffs became aware of each of the instant land from August 29, 2009 to October 19, 2009 as indicated in the corresponding column in the separate contract list (hereinafter “each of the instant sales contract”). The sales contract with Defendant P as to each of the specific parts of each of the instant land set forth in the separate contract list (Evidence No. 3) through U as indicated in the separate contract list.
(C) Around September 25, 2009, after entering into each of the instant sales contracts with Defendant S’s account, the co-ownership registration corresponding to the specific proportion of each parcel number was completed between September 25, 2009 and November 2, 2009. (c) Defendant S entered into an agreement with each of the instant lands at the time of each of the instant sales contracts, to arrange the debt relationship related to each of the instant lands and to complete ownership transfer registration, and based on the cadastral construction, to measure each of the instant lands through the partition of co-owned property, and to register the ownership transfer for each of the instant specific portions through the partition of co-owned property.
2. Defendant S has received money from the Plaintiffs.