Residential Dong-gu or below Daejeon omitted

6. Omission of both sides of the place of registration

피고인은 대전 동구 판암동 239에 있는 ( 이하 주소 생략 ) 에 거주하는 자이다 . 피고 인은 2012 . 4 . 3 . 20 : 14경 같은 아파트 414동 902호에 거주하는 지인인 김●●을 자 신의 집에 오도록 하여 김●●과 같이 술을 마신 후 같은 날 20 : 34경 김●●을 데리 고 같은 아파트 414동 205호 피해자 김◎◎ ( 58세 ) 의 집으로 갔다 . 피고인은 같은 날 22 : 00경 피해자의 집 안방에서 피해자 , 김●●과 함께 술을 마시던 중 피해자와 불상 의 사유로 다투다가 격분하여 1 ) 피해자를 살해할 것을 마음먹고 피해자의 집에 있던 라쳇절단기 ( 무게 585g , 증 제1호 ) 로 피해자의 머리 , 어깨 등을 80여 회 가격한 다음 피해자를 피해자의 집에 그대로 내버려둔 채 같은 날 22 : 24경 피해자의 집에서 나왔 다 .

이로써 피고인은 라쳇절단기로 피해자를 가격하여 피해자로 하여금 고도의 머리 손상 ( 머리뼈 함몰골절 등 ) 으로 2012 . 4 . 3 . 22 : 00경부터 같은 달 4 . 01 : 00경 사이에 사망하 게 함으로써 피해자를 살해하였다 .

Summary of Evidence

1 . 증인 한소 , 김◆◆ , 신□□ , 고 ■■ , 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 하▽▽ , 양▼▼ , 서◁◁ , 손◀

◀ , 임▷▷ , 최▶▶의 각 법정진술 ( 단 , ① 증인 김소의 진술 중 카톨릭대학교 대

There is no blood transfusion from two parts of the status of Kim Jong-tae, from the physician on duty in the emergency room of the Jeonsung Hospital.

A statement made to the effect that it was a solid temperature and that food was a golding state is a full statement.

c) there is no consent of the defendant to be admitted as evidence, so it is not admitted as evidence;

② 증인 임▷▷의 진술 중 피고인이 도박할 때 돈을 빌려준 뒤 돈을 갚지 않으면

The statement that he stated that he was fluored by finding in the house is a full statement and the statement is about this.

피고인이 증거로 함에 동의한 바 없으므로 , 증거로 삼지 아니하며 , ③ 증인 최▶▶

In the statement, from the person hospitalized in the ward such as Kim Bale Kim Bale, he/she had to do so.

The statement that he stated that he had talked is a re-statement and the defendant is admitted as evidence.

There is no consent to it, and therefore, it shall not be admitted as evidence)

1 . 김♤♤에 대한 검찰 진술조서의 진술기재

1 . 윤 ♠♠ , 정♡♡ , 김●● , 김♥♥ , 김BB , 김 에 대한 각 경찰 진술조서 중 각 진

Note :

1. Results of verification in this Act;

1. A situation report, a copy of a corpse inspection report, each occupant card and opinion of each rental house, and an investigation report (written evidence records);

16 pages), investigation reports ( CCTV investigation), response to communication confirmation data, notification of each communication data, and investigation, respectively.

Report (general), Emergency Oil Electronic Appraisal Request (homicide - Mazambamba* Apartment 414, 205) - 2201, Appraisal

Request replys (2012 - C - 2135) - Written appraisal and an urgent electronic appraisal request (homicide, board cancer* Ampha * Ampha)

T414 Dong 205 205 - Criminal and 2205, response to requests for appraisal (2012- C - 2134) - Criminal and 2205

D. 1 May 1, 2012, the addition of an urgent electronic appraisal request - Criminal and 2430, response to requests for appraisal - Criminal and Criminal Affairs

2430 Related criminal offenses subject to urgent electronic appraisal and response to requests for appraisal 2370

(2012 - C2286) - Criminal and 2370-Related, Weighter’s appraisal report ( Kim Madton), response to requests for appraisal

(2012 - C - 2142) - The addition of criminal and 2206-related, urgent electronic appraisal requests - Criminal and 2205, reduction

Equitable request (2012 - C2134), written appraisal of the law, each family relation certificate, each certificate of each disabled person;

In this chapter, the investigation report (Evidence No. 439 page), a copy of the work site, the result of the analysis of the blood trace type, the emergency e-mail.

Request for assessment (in addition to blood traces) - Criminal and 3818, response to appraisal (2012 - C - 4455), response to appraisal request

(2012 - S - 3394) - Acceptance and investigation, No. 7485, (Corrective notice) Inquiry

- Receiving and investigating - 775, 675, 201, 201 (C - 2012 - C - 2906) - The Ministry of Gender Equality and Family, an inquiry,

A response, inquiry table (2012 - S - 3394), light and screener broadcast programming table, and death diagnosis statement ( Kim.

● ) , 수사보고 ( 검사지휘내용 ) , 수사보고서 ( 현장 확인 보고 ) , 수사보고서 ( 의사 김♤♤

Other confirmation report, investigation report (general), investigation report (a report on attachment of an agreement on the situation at each time); g.

Each description of the actual confirmation reply

1. The name and the domicile of the defendant who has secured in collecting clothes on the 414th floor;

415No. 302 of the Defendant’s slurfic photo, Defendant’s photographic photo, found above the corridor,

Through this 114, the time-related photographs of the criminal implements, CCTV photographs, which reported this case to the police;

CCTV-caping photographs, field photographs, 119 post-transmission and post-transmission photographs, investigation reports (414 dong stairs)

Before the entrance and exiter of the entrance, a screen screen to screen the entrance and exiter, an investigation report (414 dong stairs)

Each image of the video images of the source (the screen after the closure of the screen);

1 . 압수된 케이블 커터기 ( 라쳇절단기 ) ( 증 제1호 ) , 왼쪽 슬리퍼 , 오른쪽 슬리퍼 , 채플린

Sports white cap, copier, copier, copir, Titrts, internal strawer, and stoves (Emb.)

The actual substance is as follows: Titrts (UB) on the part of the Titrts (UB), IBL, and DBL on the part of the two ends.

Application of Statutes

1. Relevant Article of the Criminal Act and the selection of punishment for the crime;

Article 250(1) of the Criminal Act (Selection of Imprisonment)

Judgment on the issue and the defense counsel's argument

1. Summary of the defendant and his defense counsel's assertion

The defendant and his defense counsel found the victim's boome and Kim Il-young, which had been used in the victim's house on the day of the case, but they did not have any fact of killing the victim as stated in the judgment, and the situation at that time is changed as follows.

○ 피고인은 사건 당일인 2012 . 4 . 3 . 20 : 35 경 피해자와 김△△ , 윤♠♠ , 김●● , 이 ▲▲ 5명과 함께 피해자의 집에서 속칭 ‘ 도리짓고땡 ' 이라는 화투를 치다가 김△△가 화 투를 치면서 속임수를 쓰는 것을 발견하고 화가 나 같은 날 21 : 00경 혼자 피해자의 집에서 나와 피고인의 집으로 돌아갔다 .

On April 4, 2012, 201: 01 to 00:0 on April 4, 2012, which is the following day, the defendant returned to the house of the defendant, and again came to the house of the victim, and was used in the family of the victim and Kim Il-young.

○ In the process of confirming the status of the victim and Kim Il-chul, the Defendant was asked to avoid the victim and Kim Bale of the test color sexual harassment in the process of confirming the status of the victim and Kim Bale, and the mother was asked to the mother, and the victim and Kim Bale of Bale of Bale at this time, and then reported to the police again after being able to return to the victim’s house.

2. Determination of not guilty in a case without direct evidence

A. Legal principles as to conviction based on indirect evidence

In a criminal trial, the formation of a conviction must be formed by direct evidence is able to be done by indirect and indirect evidence, and indirect evidence should not be individually and separately evaluated, and it should be evaluated in a comprehensive manner in relation to each other in all respects, and it should be conducted through a thorough and contradictory argument.

The probative value of evidence is left to the judge's free evaluation, but it must be consistent with logical and empirical rules. The degree of the formation of conviction to be found guilty in a criminal trial should not be a reasonable doubt. However, it does not require that the degree be excluded from all possible doubts, and rejection of evidence which is recognized as having probative value should not be permitted as exceeding the bounds of the principle of free evaluation of evidence (see Supreme Court Decision 94Do1335 delivered on September 13, 1994, etc.). The reasonable doubt mentioned above refers not to all questions and correspondence, but to the question that is reasonable for the probability of a fact that is not compatible with the facts in a criminal trial (see Supreme Court Decision 97Do974 delivered on July 25, 197, 200). It is not a reasonable doubt or abstract ground for finding facts that is favorable to the defendant (see Supreme Court Decision 200Do240 delivered on July 25, 197, 200).

B. In the instant case, there is no direct evidence consistent with the facts charged, such as witness’s statement, as to the Defendant’s murdering of the victim. In the absence of direct evidence, the Defendant may be found guilty of the charge of murdering the Defendant only when the Defendant denies a criminal act, and, in the absence of direct evidence, the possibility of the victim’s death by a third party’s criminal act, other than the Defendant, is excluded without a joint doubt, and when the facts charged are concealed without a reasonable doubt to the extent that the victim’s death was caused by the Defendant’s act as a result of the application of logical rules and empirical rules to indirect facts acknowledged by legitimate evidence.

The following is examined: (a) in the criminal scene, first of all, the defendant, the victim, and the third party, other than the defendant, (b) whether the third party, other than the defendant, could have killed the victim; and (c) whether the defendant could have killed the victim.

3. Basic facts

According to the evidence duly adopted and examined by this Court, the following facts are recognized.

(a) Personal information on the accused and victims and other surrounding persons;

1) Defendant

At the time of the instant case, the Defendant was a man of 51 years of age, and the weight of body is 70cc in height at 169cc. The Defendant had a disability of 2nd, 3rd, and 4th knife, with the exception of the knife and the possession of the knife caused by an accident. At the time of the instant case, the Defendant was living in the same apartment complex *** 415 Dong-dong 302 (the Defendant, the victim, and their neighbors are living in the same apartment complex) (the name of the said apartment is omitted, and only the number of houses is marked).

2) The victim

At the time of the instant case, the victim was a man of 58 years of age, key, 160 cm, 45 km, and 45 km, and there was a minor hindrance to class 4 (Non-Section 4) to the right bridge due to the malib in the malib. The victim resided in 414 dong 205, the scene at the time of the instant crime.

3) Kim Il-chul

At the time of the instant case, the right to Kim Il-chul was a man of 53 years of age, key 175 cm, body weight was 62 km, and there was a disability of 5th degree of brain-disease disability. Kim Il-young resided in 414 dong and 902, the same as the victim at the time of the instant case, and was used in the instant crime scene along with the victim, but died from the A metropolitan sexual spule on April 28, 2012.

4) Other surrounding human resources.

사건 당시 김△△는 408동 1309호에 , 이▲▲은 410동 908호에 , 윤♠♠은 412동 710호에 거주하였다 . 윤♠♠은 2012 . 8 . 6 . 사망하였다 .

(b) Gathering rescue of board cancer, main apartment, and victims;

1) Structure of the master-use apartment

In the front of the apartment, the board-based apartment is a hallway-type apartment, which has a corridor centered on the central entrance, and the front of the apartment is installed in front of the apartment (the left-hand pipe on the CCTV screen in the present tent), and the front door (the right-hand pipe on the CCTV screen in the present tent) after the rear door. Each apartment is allowed to enter only through the above two entrances. The above two entrances of the above two entrances are being completely recorded into the green-type moving-type CCTV in front of the Angrash in the front of the Angrash, among the first floor. When entering the apartment through the front door, the apartment is installed in the center of the right-hand part of the first floor, and there is no emergency stairs in the rear (the right-hand part of the front door), and there is no other CCTV in the front side of the above 1st floor (the above CCTV is installed in the front door) and there is no evidence of the first floor or the above 2nd floor in the first floor.

2) Internal rescue of the victim

The victim's house can be seen as a glass door when opening the door door and changing it into the front door, and the balcony close door can be seen as a glass door, and there is a small room and a bath room on the left side, and between the bath room and the inner room is a structure that has a main room on the left side (see the attached drawing 1).

C. Report of occurrence of the case and the situation at the scene of crime

On April 4, 2012, 201: (a) the Defendant reported the fact that a person died by telephone at around 01:21; (b) the police sent to the scene of the crime at around 01:34; and (c) the Defendant was seated at the victim’s house; and (d) the victim and the Kim Bale Bright came to go through the victim. The Defendant was killed of a police officer called to the police officer called to the Defendant (out of the name of the person being called to the Defendant) and her fling, and her fling was considered to have her fluencing. Before doing so. Before doing so, the Defendant said that he was fluenced to drink and her drinking.”

○ 피해자는 라쳇절단기로 피해자의 머리 , 어깨 부분을 80여 회 가격당하여 고도의 머리 손상 ( 머리뼈 함몰골절 ) 등으로 사망한 채로 , 김●●은 라쳇절단기로 머리 등을 18 여 회 가격당하여 뇌진탕 , 두피열상 , 비골 골절 , 다발성 안면부 열상 등으로 피를 흘리 며 쓰러진 채로 별지1 도면과 같이 ( 1 피해자는 피해자이고 , 2 피해자는 김●●이다 ) 발견되었다 .

(d) Before and after the commission of the crime by the victims of CCTV and the defendants and their surrounding persons;

According to CCTV data 2, around April 3, 2012 from around 14:31 to April 4, 2012, the date of the occurrence of the CCTV in this case, the movement of the victim, the defendant, and the surrounding persons from around 31 to around 4, 2012 are as follows (the time of the establishment of CCTV installed in the 414 Dong, 415 dong, 414 Dong, 415 dong elevator, the time of the installation of CCTV installed in the 415 dong elevator is set rapidly for about 15 minutes compared to the actual time, and about 9 minutes compared to the actual time of the CCTV establishment. Next, the time of the establishment of CCTV installed in the 408 dong elevator is presumed to be calculated in consideration of the fact that the actual time of the establishment of CCTV is different from the actual time of the CCTV establishment.)

○ On April 3, 2012

14: 31 On the left-hand side of the Defendant and Kim △△△△ Group enter 414 dong, thereby getting on and off the elevator.

He was enrolled in 205 people's house.

14 : 35경 이▲▲은 좌측 현관을 통해 414동으로 들어가 엘리베이터를 타고 피해자의 집인

No. 205 was called 205.

14 : 51 경 이▲▲은 피해자의 집에서 나온 뒤 계단으로 내려와 414동 좌측 현관을 통해 밖으

Happed to her.

15: 25 At around 25, Kim △△△, after leaving the victim's house, out of the stairs, and the left-hand entrance of 414.

I go back to her.

15:In light of 28, the Defendant left from the victim's house, and out of the entrance to the 4.14 left side.

I go back to her.

15 : 46경 피고인 , 김△△ , 윤♠♠은 우측 현관을 통해 414동으로 들어가 계단을 이용하여 피

He was founded to 205 people's house.

16:12 At around 12, Kim △△△, after leaving the victim's house, out of the stairs, and through the 414-on right entrance.

으로 나가 예산 슈퍼에 가 딸기와 술을 샀다 .

16:At around 18, Kim △△ around 18, he shall use the fluorial plastic fluor and fluorial fluorial fluor and the right side of the body.

The officer entered 414 dong through the officer to 205 the house of the victim using the stairs.

16: 54 At around 54, Kim △△△△, after leaving the victim's house, out of the stairs, and 414, the right entrance.

으로 나갔다 ( 그리하여 피해자의 집에는 피해자와 피고인 , 윤♠♠이 있게 되었다 ) .

17: At least 00, the defendant getting out of the victim's house, and getting out of the elevator, and 414, the right entrance to the right.

Throughout the country, it went out.

17:Around 07, the defendant enters 41 dong through the right entrance, and uses stairs to raise the victim's house.

No. 205 was called 205.

17: 12 At around 12 leap from the victim's house, leap from the victim's stairs, and 414 left the left-hand door.

Happed to the victim's home (at this point, only the victim and the defendant left the family).

17: At around 19: The defendant and the victim shall get out of the body of the victim, and 414, after getting out of the body of the victim.

They moved out of the Dong-gu, and moved to 408 dong, where △△△△△△△△ was located.

17: The defendant and the victim enter the 408-dong, via the entrance, and enter the elevator, and the Kim △△△△.

Neither party 1309 nor party her.

17: At around 40, the Defendant and the victim from the office of Kim △△△, boarding and getting out of the elevator, and 408 dong-dong dong-dong.

The officer goes out through the officer.

17:42 around 42 Kim △△△, after getting out of the house, get out of the elevator and get out of the entrance of 408.

B. He did not go.

17:In 44: A victim's house using stairs into 414 units via the left-hand entrance;

The defendant was enrolled at 205, and the defendant entered the same time 415 knife on the elevator.

The name of the deceased came to 302.

18: 15 around 15, Kim △△△, a 408-dong office, enter the elevator, and 1309, a house of Kim △△△, an elevator.

heading to heading.

18: At around 27, Kim △△△, through the right entrance, the victim's house using the stairs.

No. 205 was called 205.

18: 46 At around 46, Kim △△△, after leaving the victim's house, out of the stairs and through the 414-on right entrance.

After that, in order to go back to Dong-gu, Daejeon, and then play in the Kodo-do-dong, in the vicinity of Dong-gu, Daejeon.

C. Along with the day, the day was night.

20: At around 13, 14, 902, from the phone of the defendant, the house of Kim Bright, ELB, after coming out of 414, 902.

414, the left-hand side of which has been moved to 415 e.g. out of the 415 e.g.

Then, after getting on the elevator, the defendant's house was 302.

20: 31 At around 31, the defendant and the Kim Jong-si, after getting out of the defendant's house, get out of the elevator, and 415 dong.

The Ministry moved out to 414 out of the victim's house.

20: 34 around 34, the defendant and the Kim Il-chul, through the entrance, and the victim's house using stairs.

J. At the time, the Defendant was enrolled in the front of 205, with white fluor and black chin.

The state of being affected by the blaterus and the blaterus was in the state of blateral slicker (e.g., so far)

At the victim's house, only three defendants, Kim Bale, and one victim were made.

22:In 24: The defendant, after leaving the family of the victim of the married, get out of the family of the married victim, and go through the entrance to the left-hand side of 414.

The defendant did not write the above white cap that was used before that time. At that time, the defendant did not write the above white cap.

state was the state.

22 : 31 Around 31, the defendant re-enters into the right line with 414, and embarks on and off elevators, and has nine floors.

After getting up from the elevator, I moved to 902, which is the house of Kim Jong-chul.

22:The defendant, at the age of 35, has again landed from 9 floors to 1st floor on board an elevator and a passage through the right entrance of 414.

Out of the sea, the defendant's house was moved to 415.

22:38 Around 38, the defendant enters 415 units on the left, and board an elevator and a house of the defendant;

The CCTV was listed as 302, and the defendant moved to 4th floor using the elevator.

on the 4th floor and then on the 3th floor where the defendant's office is located by using stairs.

I seem to have shown).

○ 4 April 4, 2012

00: At 59, the Defendant: (a) 59 years old from the Defendant’s house, after getting out of the Defendant’s house and getting out the elevator

From outside, the Defendant moved to 414, which had been the house of the victim and Kim Il-young. At the time, the Defendant was at the time.

The magr and magrh in color, red fluor and fluor in color, and the fluor in color;

The condition in which glass were worn was.

01:01 Around 01, the defendant entered 414 units on the left-hand side, entering the elevator to 9 floors.

In this paper, after getting off from the nineth floor, I moved to 902, the house of Kim Il-young.

01: The defendant, around 05, landed from 9 stories to 2nd floor, getting on and off the elevator, and went to 205,00 the house of the victim.

(c)

01: Around 14, the defendant saw a white mother flad with whom the defendant is asked by him, and gets out of the victim's house, and then gets off the elevator.

The lower of the first floor and the lower white cap in the 414 414 Mo-dong Mo-si, and thereafter, have been laid off in the clothing in the 414 Mo-dong Mo-si.

In other words, on board the 414 elevator, the victim's house was 205.

01: Around 21, the Defendant was 114 linesd from the victim’s home to 205 lines, and was 114 linesd.

The report of this case was filed at the Aambabs box.

01:The police called the victim's house around 34.

4. Whether a person was under the scene of the crime at the time of the crime

A. As to the time of crime

1) Relevant evidence

○ Statement of Masan

The new Dog-gu, a victim's 414-dong 204-dong 204, was present in this court as a witness, and the sound at the victim's house is a letter that is well string at the victim's house. The Dog-dong 414-dong 204, a witness is waiting to see the Dog-gu, "the light on the day and the screener." At that time, the Dog-gu stated to the effect that "the sound at the "dog-dong 204" is more likely to be flick and flick in drinking people by gathering two times, and that the Dog-dong 204-dong 204-dong 204 begins.

On the other hand, on April 4, 2012, the day following the occurrence of the instant case, at the police station: around 09, 100, 200, 10 male 2: (a) 1: (b) 3:00, 2:00, 3:00, 4:00, 4:00, 2:00 ; (c) 2:0,000, 4:00 ; (d) 2:0,000 ; (e) 2:0,000 ; (e) 2:0,000 ; (e) ; (e) 2:0,000 ; (e) ; (e) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; and (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; and (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; and (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (f) ; (c) ;

In this court, the new Do governor stated to the effect that “When the Do governor was under investigation when the Do governor started the Dorama, it would not memory the Do governor.” However, this court’s statement was made after approximately one year elapsed since the date of the occurrence of the case, and it is natural that the memory of the facts experienced by the people will face with the passage of the time. As such, it would rather be natural that the new Dorama will face memory as to when the Dora was under investigation at the police station on the following day of the occurrence of the case, and the Do governor reported the Dorama to the effect that the Do governor was under investigation at 0:0 times, and the 20th Dorama program was under investigation at 0:0 times, and the 20th Dorama program was under investigation at 20:21,000,000 new 2,00 Dora, and the 20th 20,000.

Detection of the criminal defendant's happiness and the criminal defendant's clothes, which are shown in CCTV data;

According to CCTV data, on April 3, 2012, at around 20:34, the Defendant, along with the Kim Bale Bale Kim Bale, came to the victim’s house by suffering lusuls and lusuls from the black lusul, and on the same day 22:24 on the same day, he can be recognized that the Defendant came to the victim’s house. The Defendant’s above lusuls and lusuls were collected from the Defendant’s blood lusuls in the color lusul, and the response was found in the lusul, and the body presumed to have been caused by the victim or Kim Bale, and the body presumed to have been caused by the blood lusulsul in the victim or Kim Balty (Evidence evidence record 308, 353 pages).

As such, it appears that the Defendant was released from clothes, etc. worn at the time of the victim’s home on April 3, 2012: 22:24, and that there was an act of price on the victim’s house or the Kim Il-young before the above point of view.

2) Review

In full view of the credibility of the police statements in the new Gyeong-gu, and the results of the defendant's movement and the results of the blood trace autopsy in the defendant's clothes, the crime of this case seems to have occurred on April 3, 2012: 00 police statements.

B. As to persons who were at the scene of crime at the time of crime

1) Evidence of the criminal defendant and his/her surrounding persons

A) A statement of the neighboring person

○○ Kim △△△

김△△는 경찰에서부터 이 법정에 이르기까지 일관하여 ' 2012 . 4 . 3 . 오후 ( CCTV 자료에 의하면 15 : 46경인 것으로 보인다 ) 에 피해자의 집에서 피고인 , 피해자 , 윤♠♠ 과 도리짓고땡을 하다가 밖에 나가 딸기와 술을 사온 뒤 술을 한 컵 마시고 먼저 나온 사실 ( CCTV 자료에 의하면 16 : 54경 나온 것으로 보인다 ) 이 있을 뿐 다시 피해자의 집 에 간 사실이 없고 , 그날 저녁에는 코란도 나이트클럽에 갔다가 아침에 온 사실이 있 을 뿐이다 . ' 라고 진술하고 있다 ( 증거기록 61 , 196 , 222면 ) .

○ 이▲▲의 진술

이▲▲은 경찰에서 ' 2012 . 4 . 3 . 14 : 00경 ( CCTV 자료에 의하면 14 : 35 경이다 ) 피고 인 , 김△△가 고스톱을 친다고 해서 피해자의 집에 따라갔었다 . 30분 정도 앉아서 도 리짓고땡 하는 것을 보다가 난 안 한다고 말을 하고 집으로 왔다 . 그때 마지막으로 피 해자를 보았다 . 피해자 집에서 나온 뒤 바로 집으로 갔다 . 그날 20 : 00경 피고인한테 전화가 와서 김●●이 술을 한 잔 먹으러 온다고 하니까 너도 술이나 한 잔 먹으러 오 라고 하였지만 거절한 후 전화를 끊었다 . ’ , ‘ 저는 낮에 김△△ , 피고인이랑 같이 갔다가 나온 이후로 피해자의 집에 다시 간 적은 없다 . ' 고 진술하였다 ( 증거기록 39면 ) .

이▲▲은 이 법정에서 ' 사건 당일 오후에 피고인과 함께 피해자의 집에 갔다 . 고도 진술하고 ' 저녁 8시경에 피해자의 집에서 나왔다 . ' 는 진술도 하고 있으나 , 나올 당시 어둡지 않았다고 진술하고 있고 , CCTV 자료에 의하면 이▲▲은 14 : 51 경 피해자의 집 에서 나온 이후 피해자의 집에 가지 않은 사실이 인정되는바 , 이▲▲은 경찰에서 진술 한 대로 사건 당일 오후에 피해자의 집에 갔다가 나왔을 뿐 , 저녁 이후에는 피해자의 집에 가지 않았고 범행 시각에는 범행장소에 없었다고 인정된다 .

○ 윤♠♠의 진술

윤♠♠은 경찰에서 ' 2012 . 4 . 3 . 정확한 시간은 모르겠는데 , 점심을 먹은 뒤이니 13 : 00경 정도 되는 것 같은데 ( CCTV 자료에 의하면 15 : 46 경이다 ) , 그 무렵 피해자의 집에 가 피해자를 만났다 . ’ , ‘ 제가 그때 집에서 밥을 먹고 나왔는데 412동 앞에서 피고 인과 김△△가 있었고 , 김△△가 저에게 화투를 치자고 하여 함께 셋이서 414동 205 호 피해자의 집으로 가 보니 피해자가 혼자 있었고 방에는 소주병이 잔뜩 있었는데 저 를 제외한 피해자 , 피고인 , 김△△가 화투를 치다가 김△△가 3만 원을 잃었고 아마 피해자가 돈을 딴 것으로 알고 있다 . 피해자가 14 , 000원을 김△△에게 주고 술을 사오 라고 하여 김△△는 그 돈을 받아 슈퍼에 가서 술과 딸기를 사왔고 피고인이 저에게 2 만 원을 주면서 같이 하자고 해서 저도 같이 4명서 화투를 약 10분 정도 하였고 , 피고 인과 제가 소주 1병을 나누어 먹었는데 , 그 와중에 김△△가 술에 취해 혼자 집으로

B. At the same time, three obs and three obs and three obs and three obs and three obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two obs and two ods and two obs and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and two ods and one o

B) objectively understood circumstances

O CCTV data.

CCTV 자료에 의하면 , 김△△는 위 진술과 달리 2012 . 4 . 3 . 18 : 23경 피해자의 집 에 한 번 더 방문한 사실은 있으나 , 그날 18 : 27경 피해자의 집에서 바로 나온 사실이 인정되는바 , 체류시간이 4분으로 짧았던 점에 비추어 보면 , 김△△가 잠시 들렀던 것 에 불과하여 기억하지 못할 수 있고 , 그 외 나머지 사항들에 대해서는 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠의 위 진술에 CCTV 자료가 모두 부합한다 .

○ Requests for communication confirmation data inquiries

According to the Kim △△△’s Hand phone call, Kim △△ on April 3, 2012, it can be recognized that at around 08, Kim △△△△ was on telephone in the vicinity of the base station of the Daejeon Dong-dong, Dong-dong, Daejeon 38-1 Enterprise Bank Building. This is consistent with the Kim △△△△’s statement that it was in the Condo-dong, Daejeon Dong-dong, Daejeon.

이▲▲의 핸드폰 통화내역 조회에 의하면 , 이▲▲은 2012 . 4 . 3 . 21 : 21 : 08경 피고 인에게 전화하여 37초간 통화하였던 사실을 인정할 수 있는바 , 이에 비추어 보면 그 시각 이▲▲과 피고인은 함께 있지 않았던 것으로 보인다 .

2) A person who was at the place of crime at the time of crime.

CCTV 자료 및 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠의 각 진술을 종합하면 , 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠ ♠이 사건 당일 피해자의 집에 간 사실은 인정되나 , 오후 늦어도 저녁 무렵에는 모두 피해자의 집에서 나왔고 , 범행시각으로 추정되는 22 : 00경에는 피고인 , 피해자 , 김●● 3명만 범행현장인 피해자의 집에 있었다고 인정된다 .

(c) Examination of the defendant's absence in the field;

1) Defendant’s assertion

피고인은 김●●과 함께 2012 . 4 . 3 . 20 : 30경 피해자의 집에 방문하였을 당시 김△ △ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠이 피해자의 집에 있었고 , 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠은 피고인이 같은 날 21 : 00경 피해자의 집에서 나올 때까지도 계속하여 피해자의 집에 있었으며 , 피고인 의 집에서 잠을 자다가 2012 . 4 . 4 . 00 : 01 ~ 00 : 02경 피해자의 집에 다시 왔는데 , 피해 자와 김●●이 피를 흘리며 쓰러져 있는 것을 발견하였다고 주장한다 .

2) Review

피고인의 주장은 앞서 본 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠의 진술 및 CCTV 자료 , 통신사실 자료조회 회신에도 들어맞지 않아 믿기 어렵다 .

According to CCTV data, the defendant went to the victim's house on April 3, 2012: around 20:34 on the same day, and went to the victim's house and the defendant's house on the same day: 22:24 on the same day, and thereafter go to the victim's house on April 4, 2012 and reported to the police again at the victim's house on April 4, 2012, and as alleged by the defendant, the defendant went to the victim's house on April 3, 2012: around 00 and around 00:0: 00: around 02.

In relation to CCTV data, the Defendant asserts to the effect that, around 00, at around 414 - 415 - from the victim's house to April 3, 2012, the Defendant left from the victim's house and the Defendant's house was not recorded or deleted from the Defendant's house to April 4, 2012, and the images going from the Defendant's house to the victim's house at around 01-00 - 00 - 02, and the images going again from the Defendant's house to the victim's house at around 02.

However, when considering the victim's house and the house of the defendant, the 414-dong CCTV and the 415-dong-dong-dong-style CCTV are all front of the 414-dong-style CCTV, and in the case of the elevator, it is inevitable to take up the CCTV of the 414-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong Lel-dong-dong-Lel-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-dong-style CCTV. Even if one of them can be recorded out of a video recording because it is impossible for the CCTV to take up his actions, it is extremely rare that all of the CCTV in the above route did not take up with the defendant's house as the defendant's house (The CCTV is always used the elevator at all times when it goes up with the defendant's house).

As such, the Defendant went to the victim's house around April 3, 2012, around 20:30, and later at around April 3, 2012, at around 22:38, 2012, the Defendant thought that he did not have been at the scene of the crime, and that he had to escape from the ship on April 3, 2012, where he had been playing at the victim's house, at around 10:20, and around April 4, 2012, at around 0:0: (a) on April 4, 2012, the Defendant again went to the victim's house at around 01~00: (b) on April 4, 2012, the Defendant did not appear to have been present at the victim's house; and (c) there was no other evidence to support the Defendant's oral statement, and thus, the Defendant did not accept the back statement.

(d) Sub-committee;

이와 같이 범행시각에 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠은 범행현장에 있지 않았고 , 피고인 , 피해자 , 김●● 3명이 있었다고 인정된다 .

5. As to the possibility of murdering the victim by a third party, not the defendant, Kim Il-Hy, Kim Il, or a defendant

범행 시각에 범행현장에는 피고인 , 피해자 , 김●● 3명이 있었으므로 , 피해자를 살해 한 사람은 피고인 또는 김●●으로 볼 수 있다 . 다만 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠ 이외에 제3자가 피해자의 집에 침입하여 피해자를 살해하였을 가능성이 있으므로 , 이에 관하 여 살펴본다 .

A. Possibility that he/she murdered the victim

1) Relevant evidence

A) Analysis of the blood trace type found at the scene of the crime and the result of genetic identification

○ 손◀◀의 증언 및 혈흔형태 분석 결과서3 )

① The victim was found to have accumulated heads on the bend of bedclothes, abutting on the wall surface under the left side of the zone A (the wall surface of the inner and front side of balcony, the balcony closed door, and this sub-section A) as indicated in the separate drawing No. 2. From the wall surface where the victim’s head was located, the victim’s final attack on the part of the victim on the wall appears to have been in a position to have been used in a bend of the bend of the bend of the bend of the bend of the sphere, the sphere of the sphere of the sphere of the sphere, the sphere of the sphere of the sphere, the sphere of the sphere of the sphere, the sphere of the sphere, and the sphere of the sphere of the sphere of the A).

② In the zone B indicated in the annexed drawing Nos. 2 (hereinafter “B zone”), a large number of number of persons were widely distributed, the fluences presumed to be the fluoral blood transfusions, and the fluoral blood transfusions are observed. The victim’s DNA type was detected in all blood tracess on the right side of the wall, considering the distribution of the fluoral bloods, and various contacts were discovered between 30 to 60cm on the right side of the wall, and the b zone was also observed. The cluoral shock on the part of the center of the wall surface of the victim appears to have been used at the right side of the victim’s 30 cm or more, at least 50 cm or at least 80 cm from the center of the above B zone for bedclothes, and the 300 cm or more from the center of the wall to the right side of the victim’s 30 cm or more, and the victim’s price appears to have been used on the part of the victim.

③ In the zone (the inner wall of an inner gate, the wooden spacker glass, hereinafter “D basin”) indicated in the Appendix No. 2 drawings, it can be seen that the NA type was detected from the inner gate and the right surface of the wall, and the spacker spacker spacker spackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspackspacks (the left side of the wall of this zone) of this case, which is located before the left side of the wall of this case, in light of the spackspackspacks, size, and spackspackspackspackspackspacks, and the left side.

In addition, on the front room of the inner entrance where the fugitive blood is observed, there is continuously falling down from the upper shade group, which is highly likely to continuously fall down with the upper shade. As the Kim Bale of Bale of Bale of Kim Bale, it seems that a large quantity of blood transfusion occurred at the time of the price, i.e., the upper part of the Kim Bale of Bale of the Gale of Bale of Bale of death.

④ The attack against the victim appears to have been continuously committed and finally placed on the floor of the victim's body, can be confirmed by checking the shape of the victim, which has been cut off from the end part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the bend part of the body of the victim, with a large quantity of blood. Therefore, if the victim seems to have been exposed first to the victim, he would have leaked a large quantity of bloods from the end part of the bend part of the bend part of the final price, he would have leaked a large quantity of bloods. In addition, when the victim was found to have sold the victim first, he would have been exposed to a large quantity of bloods from the offender's mass appearance, and Kim Jong-il's price of the first part of the bend part of the bend part of the case.

⑤ As a result of the analysis of the person concerned's awareness of his/her blood transfusion, it could not be seen that he/she could not be seen as a trace of scattering in relation to the victim from the harmful act against the victim, so this would be consistent with the analysis of the form of he/she in the field, the order of each act, and the state of attaching the blood trace proposed by Kim Bright (which was first launched at the time of discovery of the outbreak of Kim Bright, and did not contain a large degree of blood trace), and according to the analysis of the field and blood trace situation, Kim Bright was unilaterally forced rather than putting the offender into attack at the time of the discovery of the occurrence of the occurrence of the accident.

6) Even though it was used at the center of the floor at the time of discovery of the Kim Bright, it was already used in the center of the floor of the room, but before the body of the Kim Bright was laid on the center of the room of the room, the blood was already generated in a state where the shock blood and the arbitral shape was generated, and Kim Bright was found to have been moved to the point (the center of the floor) discovered after the final attack against the victim of the crime was completed or moved by a third party.

○ 서◁◁의 증언 및 감정의뢰회보 ( 2012 - S - 3394 ) 11 )

① In light of the fact that the victim’s DNA type is detected in the zone B, the victim’s head appears to have been shocked on the wall surface of the zone B at least two times in price at the wall surface of the zone B, and the sculped blood is found to have been absorbedd on the wall of the zone B at least two times. However, the victim’s head appears to have been finally located in the part of the beculp in front of the zone B, and the victim’s head appears to have continued to have continuously moved into the wall at the location of the final price at the location of the victim’s wall at least two times after the price was set at the wall of the zone B, and the sculpous distribution was discovered in the vicinity of the blood trace. In light of the fact that a large number of scattering transfusions were discovered in the vicinity and the victim died, etc., the victim’s head appears to have continued to have been located in the part of the beculp.

② The DNA type of the NA type of the GBU, which was observed at the glass of the entrance of the zone D, was detected in the shock of the shocked fluorous typosis, is presumed to have fallen from the blood side of Kim BUU, the front floor of the entrance. In addition, the NA type of the NA type was found to have been found to have fallen from the blood side of Kim BUU, and the NA type of the NA type of Kim BU, was found to have been found to have been found to have been dead at the blood side of Kim BU, and there was a shocking shock at the edge of the absorption. The Kim BUU might have been considered to have been the price at least twice even if the head was located at the entrance of the zone D zone and the head was turned to this flud.

③ The blood trace presumed to be a sclocking of the entrance is covered by the sclosion on the side of the entrance, and the blood trace presumed to be the sclosion of the victim is also observed even on the floor between the last location of the beclothe and the wall surface of the B area. In light of the above, the Defendant’s attack against Kim B’s attack appears to have fallen out of the sclosion of the sclosion of Kim B, near the forclosion of the entrance. Since the location of the beclosion was changed later, the sclosion was covered by the sclosion of the sclosion and the space between the wall and the beclosion, and then the Defendant’s sclosion might have fallen into the said space. In light of the above, the Defendant’s attack against Kim B, as the attack against the victim, appears to have been prior to the attack against the victim.

④ It is not clear that there was a trace of scattering, which was suffering from Kim Il-chul, and Kim Il-chul appears to have not been suffering from the above spreading at the time of the instant case, and it was observed only DNA type DA type in the crime of scattering, which was observed on the side and lower side of Kim Il-chul, which was suffering from Kim Il-B, and if Kim Il-B, it is obvious that if the victim was the victim, it would have generated a trace of scattering of the victim’s fugitive, depending on the trace of scattering, at the time of the price. (The victim’s final attack location is observed in the area A, where the victim was the victim’s final attack location, various forms of scattering, where DNA type of scattering was detected, which was detected by the victim’s DNA type.) The probability of this victim’s price could be excluded or extremely rare.

B) Evidence as to the status of Kim Bright

○ 양▼▼12 ) 의 증언

김●●은 이마 , 눈 , 코 부위 등을 라쳇절단기로 17 ~ 18회 가격당하여 코뼈와 왼측 안구의 안면 뼈 ( 눈확의 안면벽 ) 가 골절되어 사건 당일 다량의 출혈을 하였던 것으로 보인다 . 범행현장 D 구역 앞 이불에는 김●●의 혈흔이 넓게 적셔져 있는데 , 이는 김 ●●이 그곳에서 어느 정도 움직임 없이 머물러 있었다고 생각하면 된다 . 즉 , 혈액이 이불에 스며드는 시간 동안에는 움직임이 없었던 것으로 보인다 . ( 얼굴을 17회나 반복 적으로 가격당하고 이불 위로 쓰러진 상황에서 김●●이 상황을 역전하여 피해자를 80여 회가량 가격할 수 있는지 묻자 ) 어렵다고 생각한다 . 저렇게 피를 많이 흘리고 움 직임 없이 이불에 놓여 있었다는 얘기는 어느 정도 피를 흘리면서 공격성이 감소된 상 태일 것으로 생각한다 . 피해자의 손상을 보면 상당히 횟수도 많지만 , 머리뼈에 함몰골 절 부분이 나와 있는데 , 라쳇절단기의 무게가 500ml 생수병보다 조금 더 무거운 상황 인데 그것을 휘둘러서 머리뼈를 함몰을 시켰다는 얘기는 굉장히 강한 힘을 가지고 뒤 통수를 반복적으로 가격했다는 것이다 . 그런데 김●●은 당시 이미 많은 출혈로 혈압 이 떨어지고 산소를 운반해 주는 적혈구 능력도 떨어져 숨이 굉장히 가쁘고 힘도 떨어 진 상태였을 것으로 보이는바 , 법의학적으로 이미 피를 많이 소실한 사람이 강한 힘으 로 상대방을 다시 제압하기는 어려운 것으로 보인다 .

○ 양▼▼ 작성의 사실확인 회보서 13 )

Whether “Bale Bright” has reached a certain extent: (a) on April 4, 2012, 2012 following the discovery of Kim Bale Kim Il: (b) on the 02th 05 blood pressure test, the high blood pressure was not measured; (c) low blood pressure was recorded as a low blood pressure ( normal 80mHg); and (d) it was presumed that the blood was threatened at the time of the discovery. As such, it is presumed that the person whose life was threatened may have been concealed at the time of the discovery of the 1.5 liter at the time of the detection of the 1.5 liter, but it is difficult to accurately calculate the blood pressure at the time of the discovery, although it can be seen that the dead person who was threatened with the life was in the state of blood transfusion or at least one liter at least one liter.

김●●의 신체상태 ( 맞아서 다량의 피를 흘렸고 , 음주상태 ) 에서 라쳇절단기로 80여 회의 가격이 가능한지 여부 : 피해자 김◎◎의 신체 중 특히 머리 부분에 나타난 많은 상처들은 라쳇절단기로 강하게 휘둘러야 형성될 수 있는 상처들로 보이며 , 이런 상처 를 만들기 위해서는 라쳇절단기를 강하게 계속 휘두를 수 있는 힘과 체력이 필요할 것 으로 생각된다 . 김●●의 사건 발생 전의 건강상태나 체력 등을 파악하는 것이 필요하

(ii) the probative value of scientific evidence;

Where the method of scientific evidence, such as genetic testing and blood type tests, is proved to be true, and the method of prosecution is deemed to be either scientificly lawful to the extent that the possibility of errors or to the extent that it would be unreasonable, it is reasonable for a judge to find facts.

Inasmuch as the fact finding is binding to the extent that it is not permissible to dismiss it without any reasonable ground even by the lower court’s exclusive authority, it goes beyond the bounds of the principle of free evaluation of evidence and is not permissible. In a case where the scientific evidence method exists in both positive facts about the crime in question and passive facts contrary thereto, the determination of the existence of a crime should be made by comprehensively taking into account the possibility and degree of errors that may arise as a result of the analysis by each method of evidence, and the facts proved by the method of evidence, etc., and the active facts proved by the method of evidence should not be easily followed by the scientific evidence with regard to the passive facts that may be proven by the method of evidence (see Supreme Court Decision 2008Do8486, Mar. 12, 2009).

3) Review on the possibility of killing the victim of the Kim Il-chul

앞서 본 혈흔형태 분석 및 유전자 감식결과에서 나타난 다음과 같은 사정들 , 즉 , ① 김●●의 의복에서 피해자의 DNA형이 검출되는 비산혈흔이 발견되지 않았는바 , 김 . ● 이 피해자를 라쳇절단기로 80여 차례나 가격하였다면 김●●의 의복에서 피해자의 혈흔이 발견되지 않을 수가 없는데 ( 피해자의 머리가 최종적으로 놓인 A 구역 벽면에 접한 침구용 요 부근에는 수십 회의 가격 행위로 다수의 충격비산혈흔과 전 · 후방 휘두 름이탈혈흔이 발견됨 ) , 김●●의 의복에서 피해자의 비산혈흔이 발견되지 않았다는 것 은 김●● 이 피해자를 가격하지 않았다고 볼 수 있는 점 , ② 김●● 이 피해자를 공격 하였다면 , 피해자의 머리가 최종적으로 놓인 곳 부근에 생긴 다량의 고인 혈흔을 밟지 않을 수 없었을 것인데 , 김●●의 발에는 혈흔이 조금 묻어있을 뿐 많은 혈흔이 묻어 있지 않은 점 , ③ 김●● 이 피해자를 공격하였다면 김●●이 받은 선행의 공격 행위로

김●●의 출혈 상흔에서는 다수의 낙하혈흔이 생성되었을 것으로 보이는데 , 피해자에 대한 공격 행위가 이루어진 위치 부근 ( B 구역 벽면 우측 부분 , A 구역 벽면 및 그 옆 바닥 부분 ) 에 있는 혈흔에서는 김●●의 DNA형이 검출된바 없는 점 등을 종합하여 보면 , 김●●이 피해자를 라쳇절단기로 가격하였다고 보기 어렵다 .

더구나 양▼▼의 증언 및 사실확인 회보서에 의하더라도 , 김●●은 사건 당시 라쳇 절단기로 17 ~ 18여 회 가격당하여 많은 출혈이 있었고 , 이로 인하여 혈압이 떨어지고 숨이 가쁘며 힘도 떨어진 상태였는데 , 김●●이 그와 같은 상태에서 피해자의 머리뼈 를 함몰시킬 정도로 피해자의 머리 부위를 80여회나 강한 힘으로 내리친다는 것은 경 험칙상 납득하기 어렵다 .

4) Review of the statement of Kim Il-young

A) Details of the statement of Kim Il-young

○ Statement by the Police of Kim Bale Kim

Do Governor First Statement (Evidence 85 pages) - April 4, 2012: 00

어제 술을 많이 마셔 왜 다쳤는지 기억이 없다 . 어제 아침 07 : 00경 예산슈퍼에서 저 혼자 막걸리 한 병을 마시고 피고인을 만나 피고인의 집으로 가 양주를 마신 후에 피해자의 집에 갔다 . 피해자의 집에서도 피고인과 같이 셋이서 술을 마셨다 . 당시 몇 명이서 있었는지 누구인 지 모르겠다 . 정♡♡ , 이▲▲은 없었으나 김△△는 있었다 . 2012 . 4 . 3 . 20 : 31 경 피고인과 피해 자의 집에 갔던 것은 기억한다 . 그런데 피해자의 집에서 언제 나왔는지는 모르겠다 . 피해자와 피고인은 사이가 좋지 않다 . 그 이유는 모른다 .

Do Governor Second Statement of Statement (Evidence 211 pages) - 6 April 14, 2012: 15

On April 3, 2012, around 00: 18:00, the Defendant was able to visit the victim’s house at the victim’s house at around 415 front of the 415 parking lot, and the Defendant was faced with memory. At that time, there was a male of the Defendant, the Defendant, the victim, the Kim △△△△△△△, and three regular cities, and the remainder was known. The Defendant was first at all, and we were late at the time. The Defendant 2, the Defendant, the Defendant, the △△△△△△△△△△△, and the rest was 902. After 902, the Defendant continued to locked at the home. After which she was not at the victim’s house. We do not think it is difficult to think that it was at the hospital.

Do third statement of statement (Evidence No. 423 pages) - Done on April 16, 2012

On April 3, 2012: around 00: 415, the Defendant was satisfe at the victim’s house, and the victim’s house was satisfe at the victim’s house, and the Defendant was satisfe at the victim’s house, and there was no idea of how she was her inside. The head was broken, and the victim was satfeed at the house, and the victim was satisfe at this place.

○○ Kim ○’s Witness

On April 4, 2012 immediately after the occurrence of this case, the police officer Kim Jong-ok, who investigated Kim Il-chul, appeared as a witness in this court, and investigated Kim Il-chul on April 4, 2012 at the Daejeon Hospital of the Kaol University, which was hospitalized in Kim Jong-chul, and at the time, Kim Jong-chul was viewed as being under the influence of alcohol, and there was a situation where he was suffering from his head, etc., so he said that he was in excess of the apartment stairs, after drinking alcohol, and she got out of the house, and she turned out the apartment stairs. On April 4, 2012, 200: around 07:30, how the above hospital was suffering from her head, etc., and that the Defendant and the victim made a statement to the effect that she was drinking by drinking the house, and how she made a statement to the effect that she was drinking by drinking the house, and how she made a statement to the effect that she was drinking by drinking the house.

B) Review

According to the statements made by the police before the death of Balter Kim Il-chul, Kim Il-chul appears to have been unable to associate with his/her head. Although he/she made a statement as if he/she were to be aware of some of his/her head, it is difficult to grant credibility because he/she could be a statement made by combining the information that he/she received from the police after being investigated, and thus, it is difficult to give credibility.

김●●은 사건 당시 술에 취해 있었을 뿐 아니라 , 라쳇절단기로 얼굴 , 어깨 부위를 17 ~ 18회 가격당하여 머리에 큰 충격을 받았으므로 , 이 사건 당시 어떠한 일이 일어났 는지에 대하여 정말 기억하지 못하는 것일 수도 있는바 , 특별히 김●●이 범행 현장에 서 일어난 일을 숨기는 것으로 보이는 사정 등을 발견할 수 없는 이상 김●● 이 이 사 건 현장에서 일어났던 일에 대하여 기억이 안 난다고 하면서 제대로 진술하고 있지 않 다고 하여 , 이러한 사정만으로 김●●이 피해자를 살해하였을 수도 있다는 합리적인 의심이 제기된다고 보기 어렵다 .

또한 , 피고인과 이▲▲은 ' 김●●으로부터 피해자가 먼저 가격 행위를 하였다 . ' 는 취 지의 이야기를 들었다고 진술하고 있으나 , 피해자가 김●●을 상대로 먼저 가격행위를 하였다고 하여 김●●이 이에 대항하기 위하여 피해자를 때린 것이라고 단정할 수는 없으므로 , 이러한 사정 또한 김●● 이 피해자를 살해하였을 수 있다는 합리적인 의심 을 불러일으키지는 않는다 .

5) Sub-decisions

위 혈흔형태 분석 및 유전자 감식 결과 , 사건 당시 김●●의 상태에 관한 양▼▼의 의견 등을 종합하여 보면 , 김●●이 피해자를 살해하였다고 보기는 도저히 어려우므로 , 김●●이 피해자를 살해하였을 가능성은 합리적인 의심 없이 배제된다 .

(b) Possibility that a third party, other than Kim Bright Korea, intrudes the victim's house and murdered the victim;

앞서 든 증거들에 의하여 인정되는 다음의 사정들 , 즉 , ① 이 사건 범행현장에 있는 혈흔에 대한 유전자 감식결과 피해자 , 김●● , 피고인 이외에 제3자의 DNA형이 발견 되지 않은 점 , ② 이 사건 범행현장 바닥에서 피고인의 것으로 보이는 혈흔족적 외 특 별히 제3자의 혈흔 족적은 발견되지 않은 점 , ③ 414동 현관 및 엘리베이터의 CCTV 자료에 의하면 , 이 사건 범행 시각 무렵부터 경찰 출동시까지 피해자의 집을 출입한 것으로 의심되는 사람을 발견하지 못한 점 , ④ 피해자의 집에 제3자가 침입하거나 피 해자의 집을 뒤진 흔적을 찾아볼 수 없는 점 , ⑤ 판암동 주공아파트는 주로 서민이 거 주하는 곳이어서 재물 절취 등의 목적으로 침입하였을 가능성이 낮고 , 더구나 당시 피 해자와 김●●은 술을 많이 마시고 취해 있어 외부의 침입자에 대하여 제대로 저항할 수 있는 상태에 있었던 것도 아니어서 굳이 제3자가 피해자의 반항을 제압할 목적으로 피해자를 살해할 이유도 없는 점 , ⑥ 피해자와 김●●을 가격하는 데 사용한 라쳇절단 기는 원래 피해자의 집에 있었던 점 등을 종합하여 보면 , 제3자가 피해자의 집에 침입 하여 피해자를 살해하였을 가능성에 대한 의문은 단순히 관념적인 의심이나 추상적인 가능성에 기초한 의심에 불과하고 , 그러한 가능성은 합리적인 의심 없이 배제된다고 할 것이다 .

이와 달리 , 만일 피고인 아닌 제3자가 피해자를 살해하였다고 하려면 , 제3자가 피고 인이 잠시 자리를 비운 사이 흔적을 남기지 않고 피해자의 집에 들어가 안방에 있던 라쳇절단기를 들고 김●●과 피해자를 차례로 가격한 뒤 그 라쳇절단기를 피해자의 집 에 그대로 놓아두고 도주하였다고 보아야 하는데 , 이는 경험칙에 반한다 .

6. Whether the defendant has killed the victim;

At the time of the crime, there was three victims, Kim Il, Kim Il, and one of the defendants at the victim's house, but the possibility of murdering the victim by a third party, Kim Il, Kim Il, and the possibility of murdering the victim, as described in the above 5. Paragraph 5., it is inevitable to view that the defendant murdered the victim. Accordingly, this paper examines the death of the victim.

A. Review of the evidence supporting the charge that the Defendant murdered the victim

1) The result of the genetic identification of the Defendant’s clothes and the bloodstains contained in the Defendant’s body

According to CCTV data, on April 3, 2012: around 20:34, the Defendant: (a) entered a white fluor and glue copier in the front of “D”, and went to the victim’s house, and at around 22:24 on the same day, the Defendant did not use the above brue and went to the victim’s house and returned to the Defendant’s house without using it; (b) the Defendant came to go to the family of the victim’s house and returned to the Defendant’s house; (c) entered the Defendant’s house with a black fluor and red fluor, and re-entered into the victim’s house at around 50:59 on April 4, 2012; and (d) on CCTV, the Defendant did not discover the 414 or fluor from the point of view different from the above fluore perspective.

However, according to the gene identification results of the partially part of the National Institute of Scientific Investigation, around April 3, 2012, Defendant 22:2: (a) at around 24, 2012, he was found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found in blood and human body in the body of the victim and in the body of the body of the victim (Evidence No. 353, 746 of the evidence record). Furthermore, in addition, even in the case of the brush, the inner and inner part of the bruth of the brust of the Defendant reported at the time, and the brush in the inside of the slus, which was found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been found to have been by the victim and the brut Kim Doe in the blood trace.

In light of the fact that the defendant's clothes kept at the time were put in a laundry and laundry and deleted the specific form of the blood trace, so it was impossible to find out whether the blood trace was a shock blood trace. However, at around 24:22 on April 3, 2012, the defendant left the victim's house at around 24: the victim's clothes and shoes, and the victim's body body was found to be part of the victim's body. In light of the fact that the defendant and the victim's body were stored in the victim's clothes and shoes at the time of leaving the victim's house, and that the defendant was found to have been considerably close to the time when they were at prices and the victim's body.

2) Analysis of the form of blood scambling on white mother

피고인이 경찰에 신고하기 직전에 414동 1층 현관 의류함에 버린 흰색 모자 ( 피고인 이 4 . 3 . 20 : 34 경 피해자의 집에 쓰고 갔다가 22 : 24경 피해자의 집에서 나올 때는 쓰지 않았으며 , 4 . 4 . 00 : 59 경 피해자의 집에 들어가서 들고 나와 버림 ) 의 윗부분 전면에서 혈흔이 다량으로 흡수된 것이 관찰되고 모자챙 윗부분에 직경 약 1㎜인 원형 혈흔 1점 이 , 모자 안쪽 땀받이 밴드에서는 흡수혈흔과 약 5㎜의 원형 비산혈흔 3점이 관찰되었 다 ( 증거기록 595면 ) . 모자 전면에서 관찰되는 약 1㎜의 원형 혈흔은 그 크기와 형태에 비추어 모자를 쓴 상태에서 가격 행위를 하면서 매우 짧은 거리에서 튄 , 곡선 운동을 하기 전의 혈흔이 부딪혀 생긴 것일 개연성이 높다는 점 ( 혈액방울이 약 90도에 가까운 각도에서 물체와 충돌한 경우에만 원형 형태를 뎀 ) 에서 낙하혈흔일 가능성을 배제할 수 있고 , 위 혈흔의 형태에 비추어 피고인이 위 모자를 착용한 상태에서 전면부의 약 1㎜의 비산혈흔이 모자에 충돌되고 , 모자가 벗겨지는 행위 등에 의해 모자가 혈액이 있는 바닥 등에 떨어져 거꾸로 놓인 상태에서 다량의 혈액이 흡수되었으며 , 비산된 혈 흔이 모자 안쪽 땀받이 밴드 부분에 충돌되었을 개연성이 높다 .

3) Blood scambals marked at the scene of the crime;

According to the Report on Request for Expert Opinion (2012- S - 3394), the whole floor of the floor of the scene of the crime was found to be of blood scamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscams, in view of the fact that the blood scamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscamscam.

According to the autopsy report against the victim, in the case of the victim's examination, he did not observe in the body of the body of the body of the victim, the bloodstains that let the floor of the body of the victim left, but the bloodstains in the front and rear part of the left floor at the time Kim Il-chul was found, but the bloodstains were rarely found in the middle part at the time of discovery of Kim Il-chul's discovery, and the bloodstains were rarely found in the upper part of the body of the victim (see evidence records 692 of the evidence records), so the bloodstains are very rare to the effect that the bloodstains were about about the bloods of the victim and Kim Jong-young.

In the crime scene, the body is found, which appears to have been left after the blood scams were generated. A criminal was found to have a scambling scam, and the blood scam scam scam scam scamscam scamscams, and the other even scam scamscams or was placed in the center of Kim Bright, and the scam scamscam scamscam scamscamscam scamscamscam scamscamscamscam scamscamscams, which were found in the crime site.

However, according to the gene identification results of the partially part of the National Institute of Scientific Investigation, the DNA type of the Defendant was detected in the part in the inner pattern of the end of the above two parts, and since the Defendant seems to have newly discovered the above two parts, the blood scams appears to have been the Defendant. Moreover, since the suspension of blood scams inside the lusulusus of the Defendant, which was the Defendant, was found, the blood scams were found to have been laid off after the Defendant was laid off due to the suspension of the blood scams from the two parts.

In addition, it cannot be said that the sufficient shape is exactly identical to the Defendant’s appearance because the blood scamtains with the upper part are observed in a state where it is difficult to accurately measure the lower part because the blood scamtains with the upper part of the base, and the shape of the scams cannot be said to correspond with the Defendant’s appearance accurately. However, as a result of the Defendant’s right pattern and comparison, it cannot be found that the length between specific points and the upper part is the same as the result of measuring the upper part of the length (see, e.g., evidence records 486) as a result of comparison with the upper part, and that the upper part of the scamscamscams in the shape close to the upper part of the knife, which is similar to the Defendant’s appearance. Thus, even if the Defendant could not be considered as the Defendant’s active evidence, it can be viewed that the Defendant is the Defendant by supplementing other evidence.

4) Other indirect facts supporting the facts charged

(A) delay in destruction of evidence and relief measures;

According to the evidence mentioned above, the defendant, before reporting to the police, laund clothes he was sleeped, slicker and her slick, and delayed relief measures against the Kim Bale, even though he was aware that the defendant was living in Kim Bale Kim Bale on April 4, 200, he reported to the police around 01:21 hours after 1 hours after 20 hours after 20 hours after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 30 days after 20 days after 30 days after 30 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 20 days after 30 days after 20 days after 20 days after 200s.

이에 대하여 피고인은 옷에 피가 묻어 범인으로 누명을 쓸까 두려워 그랬다고 주장 하고 있으나 , 피고인이 구호조치를 하지 않은 채 범행현장에서 피가 묻은 라쳇절단기 를 만지고 많은 양의 혈흔족적들을 남길 정도로 피해자의 집 안을 돌아다닌 행동들은 , 범인으로 누명을 쓸지 모른다는 두려움을 가진 사람의 행동이라고 보기 어려운 점 , 평 소 친분관계가 있었던 피해자가 사망하고 김●●이 겨우 살아있는 상태에서 이들에 대 한 구호조치 필요성보다 범인으로 누명을 쓸지 모른다는 두려움이 앞섰다는 피고인의 주장은 쉽게 이해되지 않는 점 등에 비추어 보면 , 피고인의 위 진술은 수긍하기 어렵

B) False statements for the deceased

According to the witness's testimony, the defendant did not speak to the name of the victim who was dispatched to the police officer, and the name of the Kim Il-chul, who was flueed by him, and her, and her flue his flue his flue, and her flue his flue," and her flueedly flue his flue, and the police investigation that she her flueeded his flue, and her flueed flue flue and flue his flue flue flue flue. In the police investigation conducted, she stated that "the flue flue flue flue flue flue flue

Accordingly, the police could have confirmed that the person who died by the statement of the Shin-gu, a neighbor, was the victim, and the victim's face at the time was not recognizable. If the victim was not the victim, the police did not have to make a false statement about the fact that the deceased was the victim, and there is no reason to make a false statement about the fact that the deceased was the victim. Thus, the aforementioned false statement appears to be the statement to conceal the defendant's criminal act.

C) Time of reporting

On April 3, 2012, when committing a crime, the defendant was deemed to have been in the office of the victim around 22:00. If the defendant killed the victim, the defendant would have immediately known the intention of the victim and reported it to him/her, despite the fact that he/she could have immediately known it to him/her and immediately reported it, he/she reported the death of the victim only at around 01:21 on April 4, 201 where the amount between 3:20 and 20: Provided, That if the defendant is not the offender, there is no reason to delay the report as above.

D) Non-competence of the statement

On April 3, 2012: (a) the Defendant, at around 20:34, when she went to the seat of the victim along with Kim Il-chul Kim, made a consistent statement as to the Defendant’s criminal records from April 4, 201 to April 21, 200; and (b) made a consistent statement as to the Defendant’s criminal records, etc.; and (c) made a statement that differs from CCTV data and deleted CCTV data in a way that is advantageous to the Defendant. If the Defendant murdered the victim, the Defendant would have made a false statement on his criminal records from the time of the initial investigation to the time of the police investigation, despite the fact that the Defendant would have made a false statement on the part of the Defendant’s criminal records.

5) Sub-decisions

위와 같은 사정들을 종합하여 볼 때 , 이 사건 당시 피고인은 불상의 이유로 피해자 와 다투다가 격분하여 그곳에 있던 라쳇절단기로 피해자를 80여 회 가격하여 살해한 뒤 , 피가 묻은 의복을 세탁하고 , 피가 묻은 모자를 버리는 등의 증거인멸행위를 하며 시간을 지체하다가 뒤늦게 경찰에 신고한 것으로 판단된다 .

B. Examining other arguments of the defendant and his defense counsel

1) As to the assertion that there is difficulty in committing the instant crime due to a bad loss

피고인 및 변호인은 , 피고인의 오른손에 장애가 있어 피고인은 라쳇절단기로 피해자 를 80여 회 가격할 수 없는 상태라고 주장한다 .

As seen above, the second, the third, and the fourth, the second, and the fourth, which have been partially cut off by the defendant, except for the bad will and possession of the defendant, shall be deemed to have a disability of the third, fourth (or fourth).

그러나 이 법정에서의 검증결과에 의하면 , 라쳇절단기는 그 손잡이가 벌어져 있어 힘을 조금 세게 주게 되면 ‘ 딱 ’ 하는 소리가 나면서 두 손잡이가 잡기 쉽도록 일렬로 ( 젓가락 같이 ) 고정되어 더 이상 손잡이가 벌어지지 않게 되는 사실 , 손잡이가 위와 같 이 고정된 상태에서는 피고인이 오른손으로 라쳇절단기를 여러 차례 휘두르는데 어려 움이 없고 , 그렇게 휘두르는 과정에서 라쳇절단기가 손에서 빠지지 않는 사실 , 설령 손 잡이가 고정되어 있지 않더라도 피고인이 라쳇절단기를 오른손으로 잡아 휘두르는 데 에 큰 어려움이 없는 사실을 인정할 수 있는바 , 피고인의 오른손에 장애가 있다고 하 더라도 피고인이 위 라쳇절단기를 80여 회 휘두르는 것이 불가능하다고 보이지 않는 다 .

2) As to the assertion that there is no motive for the Defendant to commit the instant crime

The defendant and his defense counsel asserts that there is no motive for the defendant to brutly kill the victim due to their friendship with the victim.

Although the defendant denies the crime, the motive of the crime in this case is presumed to be the criminal of the crime in this case, and the motive of the crime in this case shall be presumed to be consistent with all the circumstances objectively revealed before and after the crime in this case.

이 법원이 적법하게 채택하여 조사한 증거들에 의하면 , 피고인은 2012 . 4 . 3 . 피해 자가 전날 김△△와 화투를 쳐서 10만 원을 잃었다고 해서 그 돈을 찾아주기 위해서 이▲▲을 시켜 그 전날 화투친 사람을 다 오라고 한 사실 , 이에 4 . 3 . 오후 피해자의 집에 피고인 , 김●● , 김△△ , 이▲▲ , 윤♠♠이 수시로 드나들면서 고스톱 또는 도리 짓고땡이라는 도박을 하고 , 일부는 술을 마신 사실 , 피고인은 기초생활수급자이고 , 위 6명이 거주하는 판암동 * * 아파트는 영세민이 거주하는 아파트인 사실 , 피고인은 2011 . 4 . 25 . 재물손괴죄로 30만 원의 약식명령을 발령 받았는데 , 그 범죄사실은 ' 2011 . 3 . 18 . 김△△와 김●● 이 장기를 두고 있는데 , 평소 김△△에 대해 불만을 느끼던 중 김 ●● 이 김△△에게 장기에 패하자 이에 화가 나 갑자기 김△△의 휴대폰을 빼앗아 이 를 손괴하였다 . ' 는 것인 사실을 각 인정할 수 있다 .

위 인정사실에 의하면 , 경제적으로 여유가 있다고 보기 어려운 피고인과 피해자 , 그 주변인물들이 술을 마시고 도박하는 과정에서 다툼이 일어날 가능성은 충분하고 , 사건 당일에도 피고인이 피해자 또는 김●●과 다투거나 피해자와 김●● 사이에 불상의 이 유로 다툼이 벌어진 상황에서 피고인이 폭발적인 분노를 느끼고 , 우발적으로 현장에 있던 라쳇절단기로 피해자의 머리 등을 80여 회 가격하여 살해하였을 가능성이 있으 므로 , 피고인이 피해자를 살해할 만한 동기가 없다고 볼 수 없다 .

7. Conclusion

Ultimately, although there is no direct evidence as to the fact that the defendant murdered the victim, there is only three victim's house at the time of the crime of this case, as seen earlier, and there is only three victim, Kim Bright, and the possibility that the third party, other than the defendant, could murder the victim without any reasonable doubt. However, according to the aforementioned various indirect facts, according to the aforementioned facts, the defendant's murdered the victim without any reasonable doubt, it can be sufficiently convicted of the facts charged of this case.

Grounds for sentencing

[Scope of Punishment] Imprisonment of 5 years to 30 years

[Determination of Type] Murder, Ordinary homicide

[Special Aggravationd Persons] The Act on the Acceptance of Crut Crimes (Aggravated Elements)

【Determination of Recommendation Area】 Aggravation

[Scope of Recommendation] Imprisonment of 12 years to 17 years

[Determination of Sentence] 17 years of imprisonment

The Defendant did not seem to have planned to commit the instant crime in advance and did not seem to have committed the instant crime, and was likely to have committed an contingent crime. The Defendant was sentenced to three times a fine due to violent crimes, but the Defendant did not have any record of having been sentenced to punishment.

그러나 이 사건 범행은 피고인이 장애인으로 방어능력이 현저히 떨어지는 피해자의 머리 부위를 라쳇절단기로 80여 회 가격하여 무참히 살해한 것으로 그 범행의 결과가

Cruelly, the Criminal Code is very cruel.

Although it is difficult to find out the defendant's motive for murder as he denies the crime of this case, considering the circumstances at the time, there seems to be no reason to consider the defendant's motive for murder according to the circumstances at the time, and considering the following: (a) the defendant continued to resist his mistake since the investigation was commenced to the present court; and (b) the defendant cannot be able to understand that both the victim and the Kim Balbale died; (c) the victim and the Kim Balbale died, and (d) the defendant did not seem to have been able to know to the extent of the opening; and (d) there was no effort to relieve the victim's fear or pain from his bereaved families; and (e) there is no serious punishment against the defendant.

The majority of jurors, taking into account the above circumstances, express their sentence exceeding the scope of advisory sentencing guidelines as follows. The sentencing opinion of such jurors is considered, and the sentence of 17 years imprisonment shall be determined by taking into account all of the sentencing conditions shown in the arguments in this case.

jury verdict and sentencing opinion;

1. A verdict of guilt or innocence;

Opinions of the jury only guilty

2. Opinions on sentencing

Two jurors: Imprisonment with prison labor for 25 years

Three jurors: Imprisonment for 20 years;

Two jurors: Imprisonment with prison labor for 18 years

One juror: Imprisonment with prison labor for 17 years

One juror: Imprisonment with prison labor for 15 years

It is so decided as per Disposition for the above reasons.

Red leapn

Judges Jeon Soo-soo;

As a result of the price of Ri et al., the defendant killed the victim by taking part in it. The public prosecution was instituted.

The following circumstances revealed by the evidence duly adopted and investigated by the court, i.e., the victim’s coordinate

DA type of Kim Bale Kim Ba was detected in the blood trace of Bah, and a large number of fugitives located in the victim's seat.

The NA type of Kim Bright was detected, the victim of ordinary peace, the relationship between the defendant, and the relationship between the defendant, and the diskettes seen as a tool to commit a crime.

절단기가 피해자의 것인 점 등에 비추어 보면 , 피해자가 먼저 김●●을 라쳇절단기로 가격하였을 가

Although the victim is capable of being aged 58 years of age, the victim is aged 53 years of age, and the victim (Da 160cm, body weight) is 160cm, and 53 years of age.

45kg) The body level of 175 cm Kim Bale (Woo 175 cm, Woo 62 km) is narrow, and the right bridge is low.

Considering the above circumstances alone, the Defendant is difficult to readily conclude that the victim first purchased the right to be Kim Il-young.

The above facts of crime are recognized ex officio to the extent that it does not disadvantage the person's right of defense.

2) The CCTV installed in a board rock * The CCTV installed in an apartment is not taken for all hours and stored, but the movement of people is spreading.

As a result of the verification, CCTV is not taken in the form of CCTV to be taken, and it is found that the view is considerably high.

any video is confirmed to have no video (the testimony of a witness / Ⅳ).

3) The results of this analysis show that the Do governor Do governor Do governor Do governor Doo on April 5, 2012 entered the site and recorded the site on April 6, 2012.

J. In addition, the method of observing the blood trace form into the body and recording it in photographs, etc. in parallel with the crime scene.

It is an analysis on evidence records (Evidence 455 to 512 pages).

4) Weighting and antibiotic blood scambrance: This shock is conducted when the blood generated while being in the upper state is shocked by external records, such as a flag with solid parts.

It is a blood trace scattered by blood.

5) Fluoral typoid: In the case of a tool to be asked in accordance with the lower court’s power and the official rules derived from the display of the tool to be asked.

It is a blood trace that occurs from the escape of the skin.

6) Insect of contact: A body contact paper consisting of blood generated by moving blood from one object to another by physical contact;

including a stroke, a scoke, a scoke, a scoke, and a scoke.

7) Walkalks: Bloods created by the influence of heavy power, and of which movement of flag has been made.

8) A absorbing blood : A liquid blood accumulation formed by the blood absorptiond on the absorption surface.

9) Scattering blood : The blood is found in the air due to the influence of physical energy generated, since it is a criminal tool or human flag;

Bloods that are scattered and spreaded, and there are shocks, shocks, blood transfusions, strokes, strokes, etc.

10) Form dives of blood : Bloods of known characteristics or form, which are generated by blood-resistant objects;

means.

11 ) 이 감정의뢰회보의 감정서는 국립과학수사연구원 서◁◁이 2012 . 4 . 5 . 과 4 . 6 . 사건 현장에 임하여

On the scene of crime, the field shall be recorded, the form of the blood trace shall be observed by the body, and the method of recording in photographs shall be recorded in parallel with the scene of crime.

It is an analysis on the blood trace form (Evidence records 566~ 765 pages).

12) As part of the National Scientific Investigative Research Institute, Kim Dubal and the victim shall be examined by the view of the law of partial members.

13) Evidence records 1160, 1161;

Gelim 1) The inside the Dong-dong, Daejeon-dong, the main apartment 414 - the 205 dwelling

A person shall be appointed.

Ge 2) Internal 30 Scz (referred to as marked points: the point of first discovery in drheat)

1)Internal 2D, 3D Schedule

Attached Form 2 Myeon

A person shall be appointed.

(C) No. 3 of the drawing, the distribution of blood salvance groups inside the inside of the bank