beta
(영문) 광주고등법원 2017.11.09 2017누4603

전기사업(태양광발전)불허가처분 취소

Text

1. The defendant's appeal is dismissed.

2. The costs of appeal shall be borne by the Defendant.

Purport of claim and appeal

1..

Reasons

1. Details of the disposition;

A. The Plaintiffs filed an application with the Defendant for the electric utility license with the following specifications:

(이하 '이 사건 각 신청‘이라고 한다). 원고 신청일 신청내용 사업 종류 신청부지 전기사업용 전기설비에 관한 사항 사업 준비 기간 A 2016. 08. 26. 태양광 발전 전남 진도군 M, N (토지 : 1,300㎡, 99kW) 원동력의 종류 : 태양광발전 주파수 : 60Hz 공급전압 : 3φ4W 380V/220V 설비용량 : 99kWp 36개월 B 상동 ″ 위 M (토지 : 1,413㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ C 상동 ″ 위 M, N (토지 : 1,356㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ D 2016. 09. 22. ″ 위 M, N, O (토지 : 1,327㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ E 상동 ″ 위 N, O (토지 : 1,309㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ F 상동 ″ 위 N, O, P, Q (토지 : 1,478㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ G 상동 ″ 위 O, P, Q (토지 : 1,632㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ H 상동 ″ 위 R (토지 : 1,644㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ I 상동 ″ 위 S, R (토지 : 1,650㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ J 상동 ″ 위 T, U, V, W (토지 : 1,650㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ K 상동 ″ 위 U, V (토지 : 1,650㎡, 99kW) ″ ″ L 상동 ″ 위 X, T, W (토지 : 1,674㎡, 99kW) 원동력의 종류 : 태양광발전 주파수 : 60Hz 공급전압 : 3φ4W 380V/220V 설비용량 : 98.8kWp ″

B. On November 7, 2016, the Defendant entered the Plaintiffs into the Defendant’s written disposition under Article 7(1)1 of the Guidelines for Operation of the Permission for Development Activities of Jindo-gun (hereinafter “instant Guidelines”), but this appears to be a clerical error in subparagraph 1 (see Evidence A, 13, 14), which was located within 200 meters in a straight line from the main roads in accordance with Article 7(1)1 of the Jindo-gun’s Guidelines for Operation of the Permission for Development Activities (hereinafter “instant Guidelines”), and notified the Plaintiffs of non-permission regarding each of the instant applications on the ground that they were located within 20 meters in a straight line (hereinafter “instant dispositions”).

C. On September 2016, the Defendant issued the instant guidelines to Jindo-gun Directive No. 405, and came into force from October 4, 2016.

[Reasons for Recognition] There is no dispute, and each entry number of Gap evidence 1 to 14.