피고인들은 2015. 5. 23. 04:40경 부산 사하구 H 소재 도로에서, 피고인들의 일행과 피해자 I(31세)가 술에 취해 시비중인 사실을 알고 피해자에게 다가가 피고인 B은 피해자를 잡아당겨 넘어뜨린 후 두 손으로 무릎꿇고 앉아 있는 피해자의 머리를 잡고 무릎으로 피해자의 머리를 수회 가격하고, 이어 피고인 A은 넘어진 피해자의 머리 부분을 발로 수회 걷어차 공동하여 피해자에게 두개골 골절 및 뇌출혈 등을 가하고, 이로 인하여 피해자로 하여금 2015. 5. 31. 21:30경 치료 중이던 부산 서구 암남동에 있는 고신대학교병원에서 외상성 뇌출혈로 인하여 사망에 이르게 하였다.

Summary of Evidence

1. The Defendants’ partial statements in the first trial record;

1. Each legal statement of J, K and L;

1. Statement made by the prosecution against M and N;

1. Each police statement onO, P, Q and R;

1. All copies of the case of change of the victim I, such as a report on the occurrence of the case of change of the victim I, a proposal for direction, and a written autopsy and appraisal of the victim I;

1. A report on internal investigation:

1. Each investigation report (a list of evidence Nos. 2, 12, 14, 15, 16, 42, 44, 48);

1. Written opinion [9 pages of evidence], and a copy of the medical record;

1. CCTV images [No. 17,29] [Evidence List No. 17, and No. 29] [Defendants and their defense counsels acknowledged the fact that they assaulted the victim as stated in the facts constituting a crime, but the Defendants denied the predictability of the victim's death by asserting that they could not have predicted the victim's death, but the price for the head of a person's body may cause serious harm to his/her bodily function, and may cause fatal results in a case where he/she commits an attack to the extent that he/she could cause two pelle losses (see, e.g., Supreme Court Decision 84Do2183, Dec. 11, 1984; Supreme Court Decision 84Do2183, Dec. 11, 1984). The evidence duly adopted and examined by this Court, in particular, CCTV images.