아동ㆍ청소년의성보호에관한법률위반(음란물제작ㆍ배포등)
The defendant shall be innocent.
1. 공소사실의 요지 피고인은 2013. 3. 19.경 서울 성북구 C, 308동 906호에 있는 피고인의 주거지에서 인터넷 파일공유 사이트인 토토디스크(http://totodisk.totorosa.com)에 피고인 명의 계정(ID:D)으로 접속하여 성인자료실 게시판에 '털도 안난 러시아 커플', '러시아 17세 소녀', '러시아 16세 얼짱', '러시아 스쿨걸 아저씨와'라는 제목으로 청소년과의 성교행위 등이 표현된 동영상 파일 4개를 업로드하였다.
From March 19, 2013 to April 2013, the Defendant openly displayed child and juvenile pornography by paying cash points to unspecified members of Saturdays and allowing them to download the said files to be seen through a computer screen.
2. According to the court's findings of examination of evidence, each video file recorded in the facts charged is acknowledged as having the purport of committing a sexual act with the other party, but in the meantime, the following circumstances that can be recognized by the records of this case are highly likely to be adults, i.e., (i) in light of the external appearance, physical development status, and the contents of the act of the contributions, etc., (ii) it appears not to be clearly recognizable as a child or juvenile even without any background information about their actual age; and (iii) in full view of the fact that the punishment provision of this case, etc. does not simply punish the video file itself, the purpose of punishing the video file itself is not to regard it as a person clearly perceived as a child or juvenile. There is no evidence to find otherwise.
Thus, the facts charged in this case constitute a case where there is no proof of crime, and the latter part of Article 325 of the Criminal Procedure Act.