beta
(영문) 대전지방법원 2016.01.20 2015가단218300

구상금

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. On September 2014, the Plaintiff concluded a factory fire insurance contract with respect to a vinyl reproduction manufacturing plant (hereinafter “instant plant”) located in B and Busan City (hereinafter “instant plant”).

나. 2015. 3. 25. 12:45경 이 사건 공장에서 직원들이 점심을 먹으러 간 사이 공장 내부 제1번 용융기 부위와 건물 외부에 있던 폐비닐 적재덤에서 횐 연기와 불꽃이 발생하여 이 사건 공장과 내부 기계가 소손되었다

(hereinafter “instant fire”). C.

The fire certification board of the chief of the Busan fire station is indicated as the mechanical factors/heat, and the sub-part of the fire causes. D.

As a result of the identification of the chief of the police station in the Gyeongsan Station, it is presumed that the front of the melting machine and the melting machine is presumed to be around the melting machine and the melting machine, and that there is a discovery and serious consideration of the cargo inside the upper part of the melting machine and the melting machine, it is presumed that the possibility of the melting machine by excessive heat or mechanical defect is presumed to be caused by the melting machine and the accurate cause is stated in the melting machine.

The Seoul Adjustment Co., Ltd.'s report is a repair company's statement, and the completion of the work by pushing out the vinyl, etc. which was working in the melter prior to the 180·C before all of the work, must be OF and provide meals to all of them. However, it is stated that when the vinyl, etc. is contained in the melter's vinyl, all of them should be OF and the fire is presumed to have been spread to air pollution prevention facilities after a fire is melted at the high temperature, and it is stated that it is not a fire by the employer's intentional intent.

E. D’s representative, the corporation B, made a statement to the effect that “I turn all of the melters No. 1 and sprinked, I am at normal 180·C, I am at normal 180·C, and even when all of them turn off, I am at approximately 140·C-150·C.”

F. On June 5, 2015, the Plaintiff is a stock company.