A. The status of the parties is a clan consisting of descendants who jointly set up the FF as its members, and the plaintiffs were in the position of directors or members of the clan management and preservation committee as the defendant's members.

B. (1) On May 13, 2015, the Defendant decided to take disciplinary action against the Plaintiffs at the meeting of the chairman of the Ethics Committee, and on June 12, 2015, the Ethics Committee, which was held on June 12, 2015, decided to recognize the Plaintiffs as a dismissed person and to submit disciplinary action and supporting documents against the Plaintiffs. (2) On October 12, 2015, the Ethics Committee decided to take disciplinary action against the Plaintiffs after granting the Plaintiffs an opportunity to explain the grounds for disciplinary action as set forth below.

Plaintiff

A Disciplinary Grounds

1. A golf course seller at an extraordinary general meeting of the plenary session on February 27, 2015;

2. The act of piracy (hereinafter “instant ground for disciplinary action”) in which a written confirmation that the submission was to be made by 28.28. However, even though the written confirmation was decided to be submitted, it was well aware that it would have to pay damages of KRW 2 billion without submitting the written confirmation, refusing to comply with the resolution of the general meeting and failing to perform the duty of directors

2. An act of piracy, including the grounds of the disciplinary action 2.2 against Plaintiff B below, to injure the order of the clans, disrupt the order of the clans, and interfere with the religious affairs by finding the races and spreading false information (hereinafter “instant 2 grounds of disciplinary action”).

3. On February 4, 2015, if the former president scambling in the office room and scambling the danger, causing the situation where the police scambling the police, an act that, around May 20, 2015, in G restaurant around May 20, 2015, harms the settlement of the meeting and disturbs the order of the meeting, such as cutting the scambling of the directors of the executive board in the conversation with the Plaintiff B, scambling and assaulting the Plaintiff B, etc. (hereinafter “Disciplinary Reason 3 of this case”).

1. A golf course seller at an extraordinary general meeting of the plenary session on February 27, 2015;

2. A certificate of seal imprint affixed on a written confirmation to be submitted until 28.