beta
(영문) 서울중앙지방법원 2018.01.12 2015가합562913

채무부존재확인

Text

1. As to each subscription contract between the plaintiffs and the defendant, it is subordinate to the defendant of the plaintiffs.

Reasons

Basic Facts

The parties concerned have completed registration under the Door-to-Door Sales Act (hereinafter “Door Sales Act”) and run multi-level marketing business. The plaintiffs are registered in each “registration date” listed in the attached Table 2 as multi-level marketing salespersons and sell products purchased from the defendant to consumers, recruit subordinate multi-level marketing salespersons, etc., and receive allowances from the defendant.

A person who has completed the activities as a multi-level marketing salesperson in each "Withdrawal Date" listed in the attached Table 2.

The defendant's position and compensation franchise's sales position are composed of 13 stages, such as "BCD E (Newly established around September 2014) FG HH J Ha LN".

The defendant's salesperson may have two subordinate salespersons, and the subordinate salespersons may have two subordinate salespersons again.

Ultimately, the lower part of one salesperson in the name of one salesperson shall have two beams, and they shall be managed by dividing them into the left-hand one, the right one, and the two.

The defendant paid bonuses to the salespersons in the following manner:

In team salvage allowance: A accumulated one week out of the left-hand map and the right-hand map (O, a certain difference depending on the unit or product used by the defendant for calculating the sales performance of the salesperson, but ordinarily 400 billion won is converted into approximately KRW 100,000. The plaintiffs and the defendant mixed the unit P, but both the plaintiffs and the defendant combine the unit P, but the two are integrated into the same unit below the same unit).

The large performance shall be 100O's drainage, the small performance shall be deducted from 500O's drainage, and the large performance and the small performance which shall be deducted shall be maintained at the rate of 2:1, and the rest of the deducted shall be carried over mainly after:

At this time, B, C shall be paid with 10% for the deducted performance, and team formation allowance calculated by the ratio of 15% for D or above class.