beta
(영문) 서울고등법원 2020.05.07 2019나2040186

손해배상(기)

Text

1. Of the judgment of the first instance court, the part against the Defendant G in excess of the following amount ordered to be paid shall be revoked.

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. Defendant G as a party is the owner of seven greenhouses (50 square meters each) and one vinyl house (10 square meters each), located in Seoyang-gu H in Yangyang-si H, Yangyang-si, and Defendant G used two of the two greenhouses (10 square meters in total) from Defendant G on October 5, 2016, as an old-gu warehouse and residence.

B. On July 17, 2018, around 01:30, the instant fire occurred, in the vinyl that Defendant F leased from Defendant G and used for a residential purpose (hereinafter “instant vinyl”), the said fire occurred (hereinafter “instant vinyl”). The vinyls, including the instant vinyl, owned by the Defendant G, owned by the Plaintiff, A, B, and C, were set off, and the vinyls, including the instant vinyls, were destroyed by fire that were kept in custody in the Plaintiff’s vinyls owned by the Plaintiff, and the foodstuffs, etc. were destroyed by the sales clothes, Plaintiff D, and E, which were kept in the Plaintiff’s vinyls owned by the Plaintiff C.

C. The instant vinyl, the structure of the instant vinyl, was used as a residential space in which two rooms, living rooms, toilets, kitchens, storages, and boiler rooms were divided into a sand site panel (a special sponsing another material by stockpiling it in the shape of sandd position) and a sandd position panel (a special sponsing another material in the form of sandd position).

1) Examining the instant fire cause: (a) Considering solely the sand position panel type and burning form that constitutes a housing unit, which consists of the Gyeonggi Northern Police Agency’s scientific investigation fire, and the fire site identification of explosion-type teams; (b) showing the form of spreading in the direction of living room and room room on the toilet and the main room; and (c) internal walls and ceiling adjacent to the kitchen appears in the form of setting fire by the heat, the air conditioners, etc. inside the air conditioning in the bottom of the river and the air conditioning, etc.; and (d) vessels concluded at this point are melted so that they can no longer be verified.

(b) Housing;