beta
(영문) 서울중앙지방법원 2014.11.28 2014가합33852

교수임용무효확인등

Text

1. Of the instant lawsuits, the part on the claim for nullification of the resolution by the board of directors and the remainder of the lawsuit against Defendant D shall be dismissed respectively.

2...

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. The parties concerned are educational foundations that established and operated the two universities, and the defendant C is the chief director of the above legal entity.

Meanwhile, the Plaintiff graduated from the department of law and completed the doctoral degree course in the same department from September 2002 to work as a part-time lecturer or a faculty member in the same department from around September 2002, and Defendant D graduated from the department of law in 2012 and obtained a doctoral degree in the department of law in around 2012, and each of the two universities applied for the appointment procedure of a teacher with priority in education in the first semester in 2014, respectively.

B. On November 2013, the two universities established a draft basic plan for the appointment of teachers and teachers with priority in education in the first semester of 2014, following the deliberation of the personnel committee and the internal approval procedure.

(hereinafter “instant basic plan”). B University announced the invitation of new teachers for a semester even in 2014, and posted the outline of the instant basic plan, such as qualification for support, examination schedule, and examination criteria, on the university’s website.

In principle, at least 20 faculty members with 20 faculty members on the examination of documents subject to high-ranking examination shall be limited to the results of publication for the last three years in accordance with the "the weight by research project evaluation items" for at least 1/3 of the president recommended by the president, 1 faculty member on the recommendation of the president, 20 faculty member on the recommendation of the president, and the results of research subject to evaluation for the last three years: Provided, That in the case of SCI, SCI, and SCI or higher, when submitting a certificate of expected publication, all applicants recognized as their achievements shall be 4 through 6 of basic major examination (-6) and 2 to 3 of external faculty members, and the average score of each item of "the same degree of research projected" and "the equivalent degree of research projected" for at least 1/3 of the total score of each item shall be at least 4/10, and at least 60 times, at least 30 other faculty members recommended by the president and one other professor (one person recommended by the president).