beta
(영문) 서울중앙지방법원 2019.09.18 2019고단2891

업무방해

Text

A defendant shall be punished by imprisonment for not less than eight months.

Reasons

Punishment of the crime

[criminal power] On January 26, 2017, the Defendant was sentenced to eight months of imprisonment with labor by the Suwon District Court for the crime of interference with business, and on August 12, 2017, the Defendant completed the execution of the sentence in the female prison.

[2019고단2891] 피고인은 2019. 5. 4. 10:00경 서울 종로구 B에 있는 피해자 C(여, 59세) 운영의 ‘ 식당’에서 자신이 며칠 전 지인을 통하여 식당에서 주문한 음식대금 명목으로 10만 원을 지급하였는데 피해자가 거스름돈을 주지 아니하였다는 이유로 시비를 걸면서 그 곳에서 영업준비를 하고 있는 피해자의 배우자에게 “씨발놈아. 점백이 새끼야.”라고 욕설을 하고 계속하여 다른 곳에서 막걸리를 사가지고 와 식당 앞에서 마신 다음 피해자의 식당 안에 들어가 무단으로 화장실을 사용하려다가 피해자로부터 제지를 당하자, 피해자에게 “시발년아. 싸가지 없는 새끼야. 너 돈 많이 벌어놨냐. 이 도둑놈아."라고 욕설을 하는 등 소란을 피우다가 2019. 5. 4. 12:37경부터 12:47경까지 식당 입구에 드러누워 그 곳을 방문하는 손님들이 출입할 수 없게 하였다.

Accordingly, the defendant interfered with the victim's restaurant operation by force.

[2019 Highest 3245] On April 30, 2019, the Defendant requested for alcohol to the victim from the victim E-operation F in Jongno-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government, but was rejected on the ground of the closing of business hours, and was willing to have the victim flicker and interfere with the victim's business.

On May 1, 2019, the Defendant, from around 10:00 to around 11:00, 11:00, obstructed the victim’s restaurant business by threat of force, such as standing alone at the front of the entrance of the said restaurant, blocking sound, obstructing customers’ access, thereby obstructing the victim’s restaurant business.

Summary of Evidence

[2019 Highest 2891]

1. Defendant's legal statement;

1. Examination protocol of the accused by prosecution;

1. Police suspect interrogation protocol of the accused;

1. Statement of the police with C 1.