beta
(영문) 인천지방법원 부천지원 2014.08.27 2014고정357

업무방해

Text

The defendant shall be innocent.

Reasons

1. Around 16:00 on December 24, 2013, the Defendant: (a) knew of the fact that he/she retired from his/her school within the D Private Teaching Institutes located in Kimpo-si, Kimpo-si, that he/she did not want to talk with his/her his/her father E and the victim F, who is his/her father, as a matter of his/her care, and found her father E and her mother as a private teaching institute; and (b) he/she did not want to talk with his/her father in his/her mother in this place that is not through dialogue; and (c) by force, the Defendant interfered with the Victim F’s English curriculum for about one hour and thirty minutes.

2. Determination

A. The defendant and his defense counsel asserted that the defendant's wife, who had worked as the instructor of the D Teaching Institute operated by the victim, has a dispute over the victim's and his/her retirement, and that the above teaching institute was found to have his/her father in order to care for his/her own in the school for his/her long time to know about the situation of Korea at the school for his/her own abroad, and that he/she returned to the police officer who received a report from the victim while waiting in the open lecture room at the victim's request and confirmed the relevant facts from the police officer dispatched to the school, and that he/she did not want to talk with his/her daughter, as stated in the facts charged, "I do not want to talk with his/her mother, or his/her mother, so I do not want to talk with his/her mother, so I do not want to do so."

B. In light of the following facts and circumstances acknowledged by the records, namely, ① the Defendant’s phone call from his father and arrived at D Private Teaching Institutes around 15:50 on December 24, 2013 (round 15:34 on the same day, the Defendant was boarding a bus at the bus stops located 594 meters away from the instant Private Teaching Institutes, and the Defendant was deemed to have provided E and telephone calls around 15:48 on the same day, and at around 15:58, the Defendant appears to have arrived around the private teaching institute. Considering the time when the Defendant moved to the private teaching institute located on the fourth floor, the time when the Defendant arrived at the said private teaching institute around 15:54 on the day after the Defendant arrived at the private teaching institute, and the victim reported to the police around 15:59 on the time when the police arrives at the private teaching institute and around 16:32 on the same day.