beta
(영문) 울산지방법원 2019.12.05 2019가합10992

구상금

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. In order to promote the development of the Ulsan Coast Trucking Transport Business, the pertinent Plaintiff is an incorporated association consisting of persons with trucking transport services in Ulsan. Defendant C, as a director with the power of representation of the DFederation (hereinafter “Federation”) around 2007 and the chairperson of the E-Financial Cooperative (hereinafter “Financial Cooperative”) affiliated to the federation, who is an affiliated organization of the E-Financial Cooperative (hereinafter “Financial Cooperative”). Defendant B, around 2007, was a director with the Plaintiff’s power of representation and the chairperson of the U.S. Department at the place of origin of the Financial Cooperative.

B. Around April 2007, Defendant B requested Defendant C to the effect that “Ulsan Metropolitan City and Ulsan-gun filed a lawsuit against the Plaintiff, and that the Plaintiff lost the lawsuit and paid approximately KRW 850 million compensation. However, the Plaintiff’s 20% appraisal of the Plaintiff’s shares in the building and site (hereinafter “Ulsan-gun”) used as a private house is merely about KRW 40 million, and it does not remain if the Plaintiff paid the above compensation. Thus, the Federation requested Defendant C to the effect that “Ulsan-gun-gun will continue to use the Plaintiff’s share at least KRW 90 million with the money used by the Financial Cooperative, and that Defendant C received the above approval of the Plaintiff’s preferential purchase as KRW 200 million with the Plaintiff’s share at KRW 500 million with the Plaintiff’s share at KRW 605 billion with the Plaintiff’s preferential sale on August 9, 2007, the Plaintiff’s share at KRW 200578,300,7484 of the Plaintiff’s preferential sale on the Plaintiff’s share at the date.