과징금납부명령취소
1. Of the instant lawsuits, Attached Form 1(3) written by the Defendant to the Plaintiff via the plenary session Resolution B on March 20, 2018.
1. Fact that there is no dispute over the facts of recognition [based for recognition], Gap evidence 1 through 7, 19, Eul evidence 1 through 12 (including each number, hereinafter the same shall apply), the purport of the whole pleadings;
A. The Plaintiff et al. (1) is an entrepreneur who is not a small and medium entrepreneur belonging to the “C” of the enterprise group subject to the restriction on mutual investment. The Plaintiff is a package glass container manufacturing business, etc., and omitted all the descriptions of “stock company” in the name
The Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act (hereinafter “subcontract Act”) which entrusts 16 small and medium entrepreneurs with the manufacture of gold, etc.
2) The 16 business entities, including D, are small and medium business owners under Article 2(2)1, and are subcontractors under Article 2(3) of the Subcontract Act that are entrusted with the manufacture of gold, etc. by the Plaintiff.
3) 원고의 일반현황은 아래 [표 1]과 같고, 관련 수급사업자들의 일반현황은 아래 [표 2]와 같다. [표 1] 원고의 일반현황 (각 사업연도 말 기준, 단위: 백만 원, 명) 구분 매출액 당기순이익 자본금 상시고용종업원수 2012년 285,221 4,442 24,272 433 2013년 288,199 8,506 24,272 469 2014년 283,829 7,898 24,272 473 2015년 296,449 11,586 24,272 503 2016년 278,126 △2,032 24,272 506 [표 2] 수급사업자 일반현황 (단위: 백만 원, 명) 연번 업체명 대표자 연간매출액(상시고용종업원수) 2012년 2013년 2014년 2015년 1 D E 1,205(17) 1,774(19) 1,778(20) 2,540(21) 2 F G 1,030(8) 1,132(8) 1,053(9) 1,327(10) 3 H I 2,461(20) 1,901(19) 2,062(19) 1,966(19) 4 J K 13,167(12) 13,641(19) 13,164(29) 8,271(42) 5 L M 8,413(39) 7,503(37) 6,496(40) 6,661(40) 6 N O 1,993(12) 2,749(16) 2,144(16) 2,649(16) 7 P Q 6,311(18) 6,810(26) 7,313(29) 7,603(29) 8 R S 3,370(17) 4,230(20) 4,050(18) 1,550(21) 9 T U 4,989(23) 4,920(23) 5,104(23) 4,975(23) 10 V W 5,013(20) 6,396(25) 6,670(28) 7,193(28) 11 X Y 5,200(17) 5,400(18) 5,100(17) 4,800(16) 12 Z AA 1,974(16) 2,025(16) 1,951(17) 2,100(16) 13 AB AC 1,360(24) 1,496(18) 2,222(19) 2,550(37) 14 AD AE 1,993(12 2...