beta
(영문) 대전고등법원 2013.10.16 2013노270

특수강도등

Text

The judgment of the court below is reversed.

A defendant shall be punished by imprisonment for not less than two years and six months.

Reasons

1. Summary of grounds for appeal;

A. Regarding the facts constituting the crime of Paragraph 1 of Article 1 of the judgment below, the Defendant did not act as if he was in possession of a deadly weapon in his clothes, and did not mean that “if he would not bring money, he shall not do so.” However, there is only a fact that 220,000 won in cash exists by opening a credit cooperative after asking how he would take the credit cooperative. As such, the Defendant did not make intimidation to the extent that he could suppress the victim’s resistance.

B. The Defendant was in a state of mental disorder because he was almost unlocked at the time of the instant case.

C. The lower court’s sentencing (three years of imprisonment) is too unreasonable.

2. Judgment on the assertion of mistake of facts

가. 원심의 판단 E은 경찰 및 원심 법정에서 일관하여, “2013. 1. 21. 20:17경 D 편의점에서 안에 전시된 음료수 등을 정리하면서 아르바이트를 하고 있는데, 출입문에 설치된 종소리가 들려 계산대 쪽으로 가 보았더니, 피고인이 포스기(금고) 앞에서 포스기를 누르고 있었다. 그래서 ‘뭐 하세요 ’라고 하였더니 피고인이 왼손으로는 계속 포스기를 누르고 오른손은 주머니에 넣고 무언가를 꺼낼 것 같은 행동을 하면서 ‘돈만 가져가면 아무 짓도 안 한다.’고 하였고, 포스기 현금통이 열리지 않으니까 피고인이 ‘뭘 누르면 되냐.’고 하기에 ‘환전’이라고 써진 것을 누르면 된다고 하였다. 그랬더니 피고인이 ‘환전’이라고 써진 것을 눌러 포스기를 연 후 그 안에 있던 현금 22만 원을 꺼내 주머니에 넣었고, 손님이 들어오는 소리가 들리니 편의점 문을 열고 밖으로 도망갔다.”는 취지로 진술하였다.

The above statements of E are not specifically consistent and consistent, and there is no special motive for the defendant to make a false statement unfavorable to the defendant. Thus, the defendant will put the hand in the knick machine and take out the words.