beta
(영문) 수원지방법원 평택지원 2019.03.29 2018고단1557

업무방해

Text

Defendant

A In four months of imprisonment, Defendant B shall be punished by a fine of three million won, and Defendant C shall be punished by a fine of two million won.

Reasons

Punishment of the crime

Defendant

A is a person who operates E student uniforms in Ansan-si D, and Defendant B is a person who operates G student uniforms in Ansan-si F, and Defendant C is a person who operates the I student uniforms in Ansan-si.

On December 2017, the Defendants: (a) were likely to have reduced the sales of the Defendants by actively promoting activities by the victim K, which is the main owner of the J students’ uniforms in competition with the Defendants, such as “Arshts 11 event” in the course of selling the uniforms to the students; (b) were aware of the detection of carcinant substances in the J students’ Hasung High School; and (c) were aware of the detection of carcinant substances in the J students’ uniforms operated by the victims to the students in the G students’ school in Ansan High School in order to interfere with the operation of the

Accordingly, at around 18:30 on December 26, 2017, the Defendants: (a) in the Gansung-si store operated by Defendant A, Defendant A, through L et al. (hereinafter “Defendant A”); and (b) under the direction of Defendant A, the Defendant A and Defendant B were newspaper articles that have taken out cancers at the J students’ home group, for the high school students in the above location, including M et al. (17 years old); (c) at the J students’ home group, Defendant A and the Defendant B met with the aforementioned equipment. In the J students’ home group, the Defendants were holding a discount for covering them. At the J students’ home group, they did not know of such event, and were released from the J students’ home uniform, and were released from the J students’ home uniform. Using the SNS, Defendant C c took the equipment suitable for the horses as above.

However, in fact, newspaper articles, which discovered cancer in J Student Uniforms, were related to the store of other areas, not the safe area, and student uniforms were produced and supplied in different factories for each region and school, so even if they were produced and supplied in J School Uniforms produced in other areas, they were not related to the J Student Uniforms operated by the victim.