beta
(영문) 서울고등법원 2017.01.12 2016나2002879

손해배상(기)

Text

1. The judgment of the first instance court, including the filing of the lawsuit by the Defendant-Counterclaim Plaintiff, is modified as follows.

Reasons

1. Presumed factual basis

A. On February 2, 2012, Plaintiff A is entitled to the position of the parties 1) 9m2 (hereinafter “instant housing”) of the G G M&W G G G M&M model 1: (a) the G M&M model 99m2 (hereinafter “instant housing”) with the M&F around February 2012.

(2) Plaintiffs B, C, D, and E are children of the deceased H, and they reside in the instant housing from April 2012, 2012, with the wife, after concluding a lease agreement on part of them.

B. (1) On October 13, 2014, around 21:20, fire fighting began in the boiler room of the instant house and the instant fire (hereinafter “instant fire”).

The occurrence of the instant house occurred. Accordingly, the net H (the age of 71 at the time when K) died and the said housing was transferred to the said housing. In addition, the Plaintiff’s pet dog breeding facilities installed through the extended construction of the instant housing were laid down in the front and 80 pet dogs were all killed in the pet dog breeding facilities located in the raising facilities. (2) As a result of the fire site identification conducted by the 2nd office of the Gyeonggi Provincial Police Agency, the main contents of the instant identification results are as follows: (a) The location on the lower side of the pet line connected to the boiler, which was connected to the boiler, is the boiler connected to the part in which the Plaintiff and the net H were resident (hereinafter “instant boiler”).

Since the circular pumps code of the circular pumps, the order of the formation of the joint pumps was generated in the order of circular pumps and boiler electric power source cables, and the location of the joint line of the circular pumps was generated on the side that passed the front bottom of the boiler.

Cornings of circular pumps code do not correspond to plucking, plucking, or plucking, which might have an impact on the military force, but it is possible that the vessel might have been damaged by any external force while using the Pyeongtaek boiler room.

Although it is difficult to readily conclude that all the clothes of a vessel due to fire have been integrated for any reason, it is not clear that they have been integrated for all the vessels. However, this is different from this combined vessels.