beta
(영문) 서울고등법원 2011.12.22 2009나73471

손해배상(기)

Text

1.The judgment of the first instance shall be modified as follows:

Defendant A, B, D, and J Co., Ltd. shall be listed in attached Form 2.

Reasons

Basic Facts

Defendant A as the parties is the president of Defendant J Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant J”), Defendant K Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant K”), a door-to-door sales business entity, and AO Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “AO”) as the president of the so-called AP Group, a multi-level marketing business entity, who has overall control over the overall operation of the group. Defendant B is the 1 business entity under the name of the chairman of the Steering Committee of Defendant J’s head office and the 1 business entity under the name of the chairman of the Steering Committee of Defendant J, and Defendant D is the vice-chairman of the AP Group, respectively.

Defendant A, B, and D related to Defendant J-related tort caused by deception and the amount of damages mean the standard price for providing allowances to all goods as the socially weak in the PV Point from 2002, namely, the amount of purchase cost, taxes, management expenses, corporate interests, etc. in member countries.

The defendant company's "market franchise" (No. 4) explains that if the selling price of the goods is 17,000 won or more and the cost/interest is 14,000 won, PV is 3,000 won or more, the difference is 3,000 won.

Defendant Companies mean: (a) up to November 2004, 1200,000 PV; (b) one point of 1.2 million and one point of 1.2 million,000,000 SP Save Pove Pove Poves; and (c) are directly paid at the time of selling SP products.

For example, if the SP of certain products is 400 won, the member will receive a direct sales allowance of 400 won.

PV is different from PV in that it is not accumulated in that SP is not accumulated.

Although the Defendant Company did not simultaneously assign SP and PV to a single product, there was a case where the Defendant Company sold a product that granted SP and PV together in special cases, such as a failure district or drilling for a part of the product.

From November 2005, 1200,000 PV and 120,000 P were 1.2 million.

(1) The member shall be the member of the PV.