beta
(영문) 의정부지방법원 2018.04.19 2017구합12686

감리자지정처분취소

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of the lawsuit, including costs incurred by participation, are all assessed against the Plaintiff.

Reasons

Details of the disposition

On June 27, 2017, the Defendant published a corrective publication of the recruitment of consulting engineers (construction) on B housing construction consulting engineers (hereinafter referred to as “the instant publication”) for the designation of consulting engineers of “a consulting engineers for building a new block block in Southyang-si, which is implemented by the construction company, etc. of the consulting engineers.”

According to the public notice of this case, a person who has tendered at the lowest price among those who have been at least 85 points in the comprehensive deliberation by the qualification examination shall be designated as a supervisor.

The main contents of the procedures, methods, etc. for designating consulting engineers among the public announcement of this case are as follows.

4. Date and methods of submitting tenders;

(c) At the time of submitting an electronic bidding document 1) 11. A attached to the document. After the successful bid, evidentiary documents and documents submitted for the tender, omission of records at the time of comparison, and disadvantages caused by documents submitted for the tender (in the case of actual disposal, etc., the applicant's liability is attributable;

9. Procedures and methods for designating consulting engineers;

가. 감리자 지정 절차 감리자모집공고 ⇒ 전자입찰서 제출 ⇒ 개찰 ⇒ 우선순위(예비 1∼3순위) 선정 및 통보 ⇒ 사실확인서류 제출 ⇒ 열람 및 이의신청 ⇒ 사실확인서류에 따른 세부평가 실시 ⇒ 감리지 지정(통보)

B. 1) A supervisor shall be designated from among those whose comprehensive reputation point is at least 85 points through the qualification examination, and other matters shall be in accordance with Article 10 of the Standards for Designation of Consulting Engineers of Housing Construction (Public Notice No. 2017-395, Jun. 16, 2017 (hereinafter “Public Notice”), which shall be assessed in accordance with the said standards, and matters not specified in the said standards shall be determined based on this Public Notice.

The three companies with the preliminary top priority in the results of the evaluation of project performance capabilities and the opening of bids shall submit documents for confirmation of facts to the supervisory authority once within the deadline, and shall be excluded from the selection of consulting engineers where documents within the deadline are not submitted.

11. Subscription documents; and

(b)a verification document (limited to three enterprises with the highest point of comprehensive reputation) 1.