beta
(영문) 서울중앙지방법원 2014.09.25 2012가합103276

채무부존재확인

Text

1. All of the lawsuits filed against the Defendants by Plaintiffs 43 A, 115 B, and 207C shall be dismissed.

2. The above paragraph 1 is excluded from the plaintiffs.

Reasons

Facts of recognition

D and E, including the Plaintiffs’ application for subscription to mobile communications services, established “I” in the name of H through E-dong E-dong E-dong 23, around November 8, 201, by Sung-gu, Sung-gu, Seongbuk-gu, Seoul. On November 1, 201, J established the “I Forest Center” in Seoul Special Metropolitan City, Nowon-gu, Seoul, in the form of the said I branch office, and had been in charge of its operation. M, N,O, etc. worked at the headquarters or the said new forest center.

(hereinafter referred to as “H, etc.”). From November 17, 201 to June 15, 2012, from H, etc., to H, etc., from November 17, 201, to June 15, 2012, the Plaintiffs offered KRW 150,00 won per 1,50,000 won per 2,00 won per 3,000 won per 3,000 won per 3,000 won per 1,000,000 won per 3,000 won per 1,000,000 won per 1,000 won per 1,000, as a subsidy for opening of a mobile phone via a mobile phone from a radio operator, the Plaintiffs paid the mobile phone use fee and installment payment per 1,000 won per 1,00,000 won by selling the mobile phone, selling the mobile phone and selling the mobile phone, and delivered the mobile phone identification certificate directly to H, etc.:

(The part of the plaintiffs allowed the preparation on behalf of H et al. because it is difficult to prepare and deliver directly on the street.1. They agree to pay monthly monetary charges and the value of equipment without delay for six months from I to I in the opening of a Handphone.

1.The contract to pay in full penalty and the value of the instrument arising at the time of termination of the contract after six months.

1. The contract is to again provide business operators with a certain amount of money as compensation from profit accrued when moving to another communications agency after termination of the contract;

H, etc. shall enter into a consignment contract in advance with the above identification card and application form.