beta
(영문) 서울남부지방법원 2014.08.26 2013가합5894

손해배상

Text

1. All of the plaintiffs' claims are dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the plaintiffs.

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. The Defendant is a person who operates the Yongsan-gu Seoul University Seoul Hospital (hereinafter “Defendant Hospital”) at the 59 (Korean Embassy-dong), Yongsan-gu Embassy in Yongsan-gu, Seoul.

Plaintiff

A is the wife of Nonparty D (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased”) who died on January 12, 2010, and Plaintiff B and C are the offspring of the deceased.

나. 망인의 사망 경위 1) 망인은 2002.경부터 B형 간염 및 간경화로 피고 병원에서 치료를 받아 왔고, 2009. 12. 30.경 어지럼증 등을 호소하며 피고 병원에 입원하여 여러 차례 복수천자(paracentesis, 복강 내의 복수를 주사기를 통해 체외로 배출시키는 것)를 받아 오던 중 입원기간 중 2010. 1. 9. 11:00경부터 2010. 1. 10. 22:00경까지 외출하였다. 2) 망인은 외출에서 돌아온 직후인 2010. 1. 11. 02:30경부터 소화불량, 어지럼증 및 오심(惡心) 증상을 호소하였다.

Accordingly, the medical professionals of the defendant hospital conducted multiple thousands of the deceased on the same day at around 10:30, and discharged more than two liters, and more than one liters were additionally discharged at around 11:10.

However, at around 18:30 on the same day, the deceased was placed in a state of food confusion, and received medical treatment for liver brain death in a middle patient's room, but died at around 16:24 on the following day.

3) A private person of the Deceased was diagnosed as a livered liverer due to liveration. (c) The Deceased’s private person was diagnosed as a livered liverer due to liveration. (iv) The patient with severe liverer sydrome (part accompanied by multiple majors) is expanded from the patient with a serious liverer, thereby undermining the new function even though there is no other cause causing a kidy disease due to liveration.

발생 2주 이내에 혈청 크레아티닌 농도가 2.5mg /㎗(참고치 0.6-1.4)를 넘거나 24시간 크레아티닌 청소율이 50% 이상 감소하여 20㎖/분 미만으로 되는 경우를 1형으로, 혈청 크레아티닌 농도가 1.5mg /㎗를 넘으나 1형에 이르지 않는 경우를 2형으로 분류한다...