beta
(영문) 서울서부지방법원 2014.01.07 2012고정2193

상해

Text

The defendant shall be innocent.

Reasons

1. On May 10, 2012, the Defendant: (a) as a driver of an urban bus driver, the Defendant: (b) around 10:10 on May 10, 2012; (c) around D Hospital shuttle bus driven by the victim E on the road in front of the D Hospital emergency room located in Seodaemun-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government; and (d) on the ground that the bus driven by the Defendant is against each other, it is obvious that the bus faced with each other, and that the bus driven by the Defendant, e.g., e., a defect, and e., a defect, e., the face of the victim; and (d) on the ground that the microphone installed inside the bus due to

2. Each victim’s statement (legal statement, police statement), injury diagnosis statement, injury photograph and CCTV image are included in evidence consistent with the facts charged in the instant case.

The victim stated in an investigative agency that the victim was at the time of the victim's face by displaying the victim's face through the window in front of the bus in which the victim was driven by the victim, and that the victim was at the time of the victim's face, but this court stated that the victim was at the face of the victim who talked through the bus window of the defendant and the bus window, and later, the victim was at the end, and the victim was at the face of the victim, and the statement was not consistent. The above CCTV image was not consistent. The victim was at the face of the victim's face, but the victim was at the face of the victim's face, and the victim did not contact the victim's face, and the victim was able to avoid the victim's loss.

According to the above CCTV images, the victim did not have a face suitable for the victim because of the microphones of the bus that the victim is driving, and according to the above CCTV images, the victim immediately moved to the bus entrance after the defendant putting his hand as above and immediately moved to the bus entrance and brought a dispute with the defendant, and there was no face of the debris, and the head and the part of the body of the victim in the state where the cause of the injury to the defendant was seated.