beta
(영문) 서울동부지방법원 2012.12.20 2012노1213

방문판매등에관한법률위반등

Text

All appeals by the Defendants are dismissed.

Reasons

1. The summary of the grounds for appeal (e.g., a two-year imprisonment) of the lower court (e.g., a one-year imprisonment) is excessively unreasonable.

2. The circumstances are that the Defendants recognized the instant crime and are detained in prison for six to seven months, and that the Defendants deposited KRW 2 million for the victim G when they came to the trial, and that there was no record of criminal punishment for the same crime, and that Defendant C and F are not good for the health of family members and are difficult to live.

However, the defendants' crime of this case was committed by the 20th early middle-class young people without social experience, forced them to enter into an education camp and contract, induce them to enter into a false and exaggerated contract, and encourage them to purchase goods with approximately KRW 6.3 billion on a total of 1,565 occasions on condition of registration, and the quality of the crime is very poor. Defendant B continued to engage in several multi-level companies even before the crime of this case was committed, and the corporation of this case seems to have been actually operated. Defendant C and F participated in the multi-level organizations prior to the crime of this case and also play a leading role in the Z, which led to the fact that Defendant C participated in the multi-level organizations before the crime of this case. Defendant C had been sentenced two times of fines and one suspended sentence of imprisonment for the same crime, and Defendant F had the record of being sentenced to one suspended sentence of imprisonment for the same kind of crime, and even if it appears that the defendants were not responsible for the same kind of crime to the extent that they did not reach the judgment of the court below.