beta
(영문) 서울서부지방법원 2018.01.26 2017가단202862

대여금

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Reasons

1. Facts of recognition;

A. C (the plaintiff's spouse D's son's son's son's son's son's son's son's son's son's son's son's son's her son

C's fault G adopted the defendant and reported him falsely as his father.

B. around November 2001, C re-entered E in the housing located in Jongno-gu Seoul Jongno-gu Seoul, and operated the restaurant in the trade name of “J” in the neighboring Seoul Jongno-gu I.

On the other hand, C and E maintained de facto marriage without reporting marriage.

C. From June 13, 201 to February 2, 2015, the Plaintiff remitted total of KRW 82,300,000 to E to the Plaintiff’s account or the Plaintiff’s K account as indicated in the following table.

순번 입금일자 입금 금액(원) 입금자 비고 1 2011.06.13. 6,000,000 원고 갑 제2호증 2 2011.06.13. 6,000,000 원고 3 2011.06.13. 6,000,000 원고 4 2011.06.13. 4,500,000 원고 5 2011.12.13. 4,000,000 K 갑 제3호증의 1 6 2011.12.13. 1,000,000 K 7 2012.05.15. 2,000,000 K 8 2012.12.10. 3,000,000 K 9 2013.01.21. 6,000,000 K 10 2013.07.18. 5,000,000 K 11 2013.09.06. 4,500,000 K 12 2013.11.05. 1,500,000 K 13 2013.12.04. 1,000,000 K 14 2014.01.28. 600,000 K 15 2014.02.18. 1,000,000 K 16 2014.03.15. 3,000,000 K 17 2014.03.19. 5,000,000 K 18 2014.04.10. 6,000,000 K 19 2014.05.15. 1,000,000 K 20 2014.06.30. 1,000,000 K 21 2014.07.28. 1,000,000 K 22 2014.08.08. 1,000,000 K 23 2014.08.19. 700,000 K 24 2014.08.27. 1,000,000 K 25 2014.09.17. 2,000,000 K 26 2014.10.28. 3,000,000 K 27 2014.12.09. 1,000,000 K 28 2014.12.19. 1,000,000 K 29 2015.01.06. 3,000,000 K 30 2015.02.02. 500,000 K 합계 82,300,000

D. On April 1, 2015, E received an operation with a cardiopulmonary light on a sudden basis, and died on the 28th of the same month.

E. The Defendant filed a claim for recognition with the Seoul Family Court 2015ddan26859, and the Seoul Family Court accepted the above claim for recognition on July 14, 2016 on the ground that “the Defendant’s natural father is obvious.”

F. On October 25, 2016, the Defendant is Jongno-gu Seoul Metropolitan Government L site and land owned by E.