A. The plaintiffs are the sectional owners of AH building listed in the attached Table AH building in Seoul Special Metropolitan City, Nowon-gu's ground list (hereinafter "instant commercial building"), and the aggregate of the ownership ratio of the above land according to the ratio of the area of the whole part of the building is as stated in the "share ratio" in the attached Table.

B. The Defendants are members of the AI association members’ shop owners’ association (hereinafter “the instant council”) composed of the sectional owners of the instant commercial building and their spouses or lineal ascendants and descendants (hereinafter “the instant council”), who were declared to have been appointed as executive officers by Defendant U at the regular general assembly of July 15, 201 (hereinafter “instant general assembly”).

C. While the present assembly continues to comply with the present assembly, Defendant U presented an agenda for the improvement of parking lot facilities and the removal and maintenance of the five-story air-conditioning and heating facilities underground, and it was declared that there is no objection, but it continued to be a dispute over the validity of the above assembly, such as that some members leave the said assembly.

The Defendants attended the 115th board of directors of the instant Council (hereinafter “the instant board of directors”) held on August 8, 2011, and resolved to remove the five-story heating and cooling facilities from the Korea-Demolitioning enterprise with KRW 15,000,000. Accordingly, from August 11, 201 to September 19, 2011, the five-story heating and cooling facilities and equipment rooms of the instant commercial building were entirely removed (hereinafter “instant facilities”).

E. On September 30, 201, Plaintiff A and Plaintiff B filed a lawsuit against the instant council on the confirmation of invalidity of the general assembly resolution at the Seoul Northern District Court 201Kahap8984, and sentenced on February 23, 2012, “The instant general assembly confirmed that the resolution that the Defendants appointed the Defendants as officers of the instant council at the general assembly, the resolution on the improvement of parking lot facilities, and the removal and maintenance of the five-story heating and cooling facilities at the underground level is each invalid,” and the said judgment on March 13, 2012.