beta
(영문) 서울행정법원 2013.11.05 2012구합21239

과징금부과처분취소

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. Of the costs of the lawsuit, the part pertaining to the participation by the Plaintiff’s Intervenor is as follows.

Reasons

1. Details of the disposition;

A. The F market (hereinafter “instant building”) is a commercial building built on the first floor and third floor above the ground level around 1979 in Jung-gu Seoul, Jung-gu, Seoul and H on the upper ground level around 1979.

B. From July 1998, the Plaintiff is serving as the representative director of I Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Nonindicted Company”) established with the management, etc. of the entire building of this case from around July 1998, and the Intervenor E (hereinafter “ Intervenor”) is the Plaintiff’s wife and the Intervenor D are the Plaintiff.

In addition, the Intervenor B worked for an auditor or director after 1997 in J, Inc., the Plaintiff’s operation, and managed the Plaintiff’s and his family’s property. The Intervenor C worked for a L company with the Plaintiff’s shares while working for a management office for more than 10 years in K, which was previously operated by the Plaintiff, and is working for a L company with the Plaintiff’s shares at the time of the development project for the underground parking lot of the building of this case, and is serving as a director or representative director since 198.

The intervenor B, C (T 1/2 shares each), 8 March 16, 2001, on the date of the registration date and the registration date of February 7, 2001, Nos. 6, 2001, No. 10, Jun. 5, 2002, 2002, No. 10, Jun. 5, 2002, the trade participant D (the entire transfer of P shares by the intervenor) No. 11, Feb. 7, 2001, No. 11377, Jul. 11, 2002, the trade participant E trade participant E on February 7, 2001

C. At the time of new construction, the first floor of the instant building consists of the section for common use in which parking lots, substations, communications rooms, etc. are located and the section for common use and the section for uniting.

Among the parts of the above sectional ownership, the stores of subparagraphs 6, 8, 10, and 11 of the underground floor located G are referred to as "each of subparagraphs 6, 8, 10, and 11", and "each of the above sectional ownership" is referred to as "each of the above stores."

Although it was attached to underground parking lots, fire walls were divided into boundaries.

Each of the stores in this case was owned by the O, and is as listed below.