beta
(영문) 서울북부지방법원 2016.09.27 2016가단106923

소유권말소등기

Text

1. The plaintiff's lawsuit against the defendant B is dismissed, and the defendant C's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit are assessed against the Plaintiff.

Reasons

1. Grounds for not accepting the Plaintiff’s claim of this case against Defendant C

A. The facts acknowledged in Changwon District Court Decision 2009Gahap5209 Decided April 8, 2010 (Final District Court Decision 2009Gahap5209 decided; Na 1) were (1) the plaintiff's creditor's compulsory auction against the apartment house newly constructed and acquired by the plaintiff ("the building of this case") which was originally acquired by the plaintiff ("part of the building of this case") was made on April 2, 2003, and the decision to commence the auction (J, K (K) was completed on April 2, 2003, each of the above apartment houses including the building of this case was completed on April 2, 2003.

(2) On April 9, 2003, the Plaintiff entered into a pre-sale agreement with L on the instant building, etc. and completed the provisional registration of the right to claim ownership transfer against L.

(3) 그 후 원고는 이 사건 건물 등을 포함한 위 공동주택 120세대를 담보로 M와 N 측으로부터 23억 원을 차용하기로 마음먹고, ① 2003. 6. 5. N에게 수취인 N, 발행일 2003. 6. 5., 액면 19억 5,000만원, 지급기일 백지로 된 약속어음 1장을 발행교부하면서, 그날 N으로부터 13억원을 이자 월 3%, ‘변제기 2003. 9. 5.’로 정하여 차용한다는 내용이 담긴 ‘차용지불약정서’와 그 13억 원을 수령하였다는 취지가 적힌 ‘영수증’도 함께 건넸고, ② 이와 별도로 원고는 2003년경 M에게도 수취인 M, 지급기일 2003. 4. 9., 액면 10억원, 발행일 백지로 된 약속어음 1장을 발행교부하였다.

(4) Accordingly, on June 5, 2003, N and M acquired L’s right to transfer ownership regarding the instant building, etc. in order to secure the payment of the above loan claims, and completed the additional registration of the provisional registration of the right to claim ownership transfer (each one-half share). On the same day, the Plaintiff registered the creation of the right to collateral security of KRW 1950 million with respect to the instant building, etc. in the N, and registered the creation of the right to collateral security of KRW 1.5 billion with the maximum debt amount in M.