beta
(영문) 서울중앙지방법원 2016.06.01 2014가합53443

하자보수에 갈음하는 손해배상 등

Text

1. The plaintiff's lawsuit against the plaintiff's comprehensive construction, green city construction, and city construction company.

Reasons

A. Since the height of the floor above the floor is likely to cause any trouble to the function, safety, and aesthetic view, it is difficult to deem that the appraisal result of an appraiser who calculated the cost of reconstruction after the removal is unreasonable.

An appraiser who did not perform the work of collecting and constructing a lusium in a public-use 85 complex applied the "general person 0.04055" per cubic meter at the time of calculating the cost of repairing the defects, but it is reasonable to apply the "general person 0.006814" to the "general person 0.06814 person per cubic meter in cubic meter according to the method of calculating the cost

Since the defect repair is not only annexed to miscellaneous, but also includes the establishment of a diplomatic mission, it is difficult to see that the appraisal result of the appraiser is unfair.

86.An appraiser of excellent drainage siren in the complex calculated the cost of construction of sirens of specifications that are not normally used.

An appraiser shall refer to the plan of the drainage plan of the approved drawing, and in consideration of the fact that the installation section of the siren is the outside exposed section, the difference between the construction cost incurred for the construction of a siren for the use of the water from 10*50*4m as the cost of repairing defects. It is difficult to see that the appraiser's appraisal result is unfair.

As a result, the main entrance floor of the B1st floor and the landscaped construction floor (high pressure block) of each 21st floor were constructed with a sloped by raising approximately 20 meters more than the landscaped construction floor, and rainwater was constructed so as not to cross the main entrance and exit from the main entrance and exit.

It is recognized that the difference between the end of the main entrance floor and the end of the floor of the landscaped construction works of the apartment of this case is different from the approved drawings, and the function of rainwater to the inside of the main entrance and exit of rainwater is recognized.

Article 10 of the Fire Safety Standards (Notification by the Fire Prevention Agency) of the sprinkler equipment that causes the spuging impairment of the underground parking lot for public use 140 refers to ① the distance from the attachment surface of the sprinklerr, ② the case where there is an obstacle.