beta
(영문) 대구지방법원김천지원 2015.08.27 2014가단3524

사용료

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff is engaged in a mid-term rental business with the trade name “C (D)”, and the Defendant is engaged in a facility business, such as pipeline construction and electrical construction, with the trade name “E”.

B. Jinchi Industries Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Jinchi Industries”) awarded a contract for the installation of air compressions upon retirement of a branch factory to EPPP Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “EPP”). EPP subcontracted the Defendant’s work of replacing the compressed machines of 2.5 tons in the above installation work (hereinafter “instant machines”) from EPP to the Apt compresseds compressed machines produced from EPP to the Plaintiff during the said installation work.

C. On November 1, 2013, the Defendant entered into a service agreement with the Plaintiff on November 1, 2013, with the content that the instant machinery on the second floor of a factory in Jinyoung District would transport the instant machinery on the first floor and pay a fee of KRW 600,000 (AT separately) with the fee for the use thereof.

On November 1, 2013, the Plaintiff and the Defendant transported the instant machinery through the following process, and there was an accident of destruction of the machinery (hereinafter “instant accident”) due to the collision with the Plaintiff’s cranes, while leaving the instant machinery back to the floor.

1) The instant machinery on the 2nd floor of the Jinyoung-gu Factory is a door leaving the 2nd floor (hereinafter referred to as “second floor entrance”).

)까지 약 5~6m 떨어져 위치해 있었고, 약 2.5톤의 무게가 나갔다. 2) 피고측 직원들은 이 사건 기계를 2층 출입문까지 운반하기 위하여 이 사건 기계의 고정된 부분을 해제한 후 벽면에 고정되어 있던 다른 압축기계와 이 사건 기계를 직경∮ 건설용어로서 직경단위 파이, 1∮= 1mm 20인 밧줄(이하 ‘이 사건 밧줄’이라 한다)로 연결하였고, 보다 쉽게 기계를 운반하기 위해 이 사건 기계 밑에 직경 ∮60인 쇠파이프 여러 개를 놓았다.

3. The Defendant’s employees have shown the instant machinery.