beta
(영문) 서울북부지방법원 2016.07.06 2015가합24595

손해배상(기)

Text

1. The plaintiff's claim is dismissed.

2. The costs of lawsuit shall be borne by the Plaintiff.

Reasons

1. Basic facts

A. The Defendant decided a supplier of ESCO services (hereinafter “instant project”) operated by the Defendant’s Seoul Foreign Language High School (hereinafter “Seoul Foreign Language High School”) through electronic bidding (hereinafter “instant bidding”), and the head of the Seoul Foreign Language High School published the instant project on July 21, 2015 (Public Notice No. 201507947-00) (Public Notice No. 201, 2015), along with a tender notice and a prospectus (hereinafter “instant prospectus”). The main contents related to the instant project are as follows:

The actual accounts are as follows: estimated price for 30 days from the date of commencement of the project replacing 32 W of existing light light such as 106,151,000 won from the date of the project announcement to 14W (the type and quantity of light are see prospectus) 30 days from the date of commencement of the project: Value-added Tax of 96,50,091 won: 106,151,000 won: 106,151,000 won

1. Matters referred to the tender;

5. Methods of selecting successful bidders;

(c)Pre-qualification examination scores will be calculated for participating companies (including companies below the successful bid ratio, due to the business effects allocated to the criteria for eligibility examination are the counter-evaluation by order of ESSCO ranking).

It shall be examined in the order of the lowest bidder as a successful bidder (at least 87.745% of the successful bidder's price) below the estimated price (at least the lowest price), and shall be determined as a successful tenderer whose comprehensive score (pre-qualification score) according to the evaluation criteria is at least 95 points

(e) In such cases, if the minimum points are less than those that can be determined as a successful tenderer, the successful tenderer shall be determined in the order of bidders after examining the lowest points in the order of bidders.

The actual tax invoice shall be

Ⅰ. Service description.

4. Project outline;

(a) Fluorescent lamps (including stability lamps), replacements, etc.;

(b) Replacements: (1,605) the detailed specifications of each of the two existing replacement specifications;