(영문) 서울고등법원 2019.10.17 2018나2066150



1. Of the judgment of the court of first instance, the part against the Plaintiff A, which orders payment below, shall be revoked.


Basic Facts

The defendant is a medical corporation that operates a hospital located in Bupyeong-gu Incheon Metropolitan City H (hereinafter referred to as the "Defendant Hospital").


A is diagnosed as the escape certificate by the defendant hospital as follows and received an operation treatment for him, and the plaintiff B is the spouse of the plaintiff.

On June 30, 2016, the diagnosis of the escape from the defendant hospital and the conical signboard A was filed with the defendant hospital by asserting that the entangled cucks, bucks, the paper spacks, and the floor spacks started from a month. On the same day, the result of the CT test conducted by the defendant hospital around 15:27 on the same day, the defendant hospital observed that the expansion of conical signboards No. 3-4, the escape symptoms of the conical large-scale prone signboard in the 4-5 vert, the verted vertebrop escape symptoms in the vertece No. 5, and the opinion of the escape symptoms of the conical signboard No. 1, the defendant hospital was in need of a clinical treatment on the escape certificate of the plaintiff A's reical signboard No. 4-5.

On the other hand, in the case of the Do basin examination in which the same day has been implemented against the above plaintiffs, both sides of the low excavation in both sides of the 5th class 5 and the 5th class 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 5 level 1.

This is an objective indicator to assess the patient's vision or aggravation in comparison with the move of the government before and after the operation.

was measured by the Corporation.


A was born again to the Defendant Hospital on July 4, 2016, which was implemented at around 09:10 on the same day, and the opinions such as the results of the RoI test were observed as a result of the RoI test on the RoI test, which was implemented at around 10:09 on the same day, and the following was observed on both the 5th celebism and the 1th celebism test, and the 5th celebism of the 5th leth eth eth eth eth .