2. Although there are circumstances that can be considered as favorable circumstances, such as the fact that the Defendants were punished by the court of the Republic of Korea from the court of the Republic of Korea, and all of their criminal acts are recognized to be committed, and against the fact that most of the acquired money and valuables were confiscated before they were taken out to China, the Defendants would receive compensation from the principal offender in China, and only share simple roles such as purchase activities among the crimes in this case. However, the crimes in this case are organized an international organization that forges several overseas bank credit cards, and then acquired property by means of purchasing goods from various overseas department stores in the Republic of Korea with forged credit cards, and the nature of such crimes is very significant. The acquired money and the acquired money are KRW 2888 million,000,000,000,000 won, and the amount of the attempted money and the amount of damage are very unfavorable to the Defendants, together with the circumstances that are similar to the punishment in this case, the Defendants’ contributions to the crime in this case, the degree of punishment and punishment of the Defendants, as well as the motive and motive of the motive of the crime in this case.

3. As such, the Defendants’ appeal is dismissed in accordance with Article 364(4) of the Criminal Procedure Act, since all of the appeals are without merit. It is so decided as per Disposition.