A. From 2003 to 2003, Plaintiff A live together with Plaintiff B, his wife, Plaintiff C, and Plaintiff D, who are the wife of Plaintiff F building G, and runs an electric material rental wholesale and retail business with the trade name “I” on the first floor of the H ground of the Daegu Suwon-gu H building.

B. The Defendant is operating beauty rooms on the first floor of the Daegu-gu J-gu Ground Building located adjacent to the 8th line of the I shop.

다. 피고는 원고 A이 자신을 몰래 훔쳐본다고 생각하고 2017. 5.경부터 2018. 3.경까지 포털사이트 K의 인터넷 기사에 “L에 있는 C이 아빠, 8년을 일욜, 휴가철, 명절 전날 새벽에 나와 역겨운 표정, 싫다라는 내 표정을 읽은 후 즐기기 시작하죠, 부인은 휴무 때 가게 나오는거 싫다는데, 남편이 자기말을 안 듣자 자존심도 상하고, 자꾸 내 문제로 싸우자니 괴롭거덩, 나랑 눈 맞추고 나서야 들감, 뚱땡인 평일엔 손님들 붙잡고 날 흉보죠, 니 딸년은 귀하디 내가 있는 공간에 오고싶어 집착 남잔 못생기고 뚱뚱한 마누라 말을 들을 리가 없지, 표정이 불행해보여” 등 원고 A, B을 비방하는 내용의 댓글을 지속적으로 게시하였다. 라.

Plaintiff

A filed a complaint against the Defendant as a violation of Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection (Defamation) around April 2018.

On August 31, 2018, the defendant was issued a summary order of KRW 3 million at the Daegu District Court (2018 High Court Decision 9499) and filed a request for formal trial.

On June 18, 2019, the Daegu District Court sentenced the Defendant to a fine of KRW 1.5 million.

(2018 High Court Decision 1345). The defendant's appeal is pending in the appellate court.

(Tgu District Court 2019No2561). (e)

From the end of 2018, the defendant found the apartment that the plaintiffs live and started to photograph the photographic image when the plaintiffs appear. Since the end of 2018, the defendant's beauty room operated by the defendant.