beta
(영문) 대구지방법원 2018.08.17 2018노1511

상해

Text

The prosecutor's appeal is dismissed.

Reasons

1. The summary of the grounds of appeal is as follows: (a) there are two separate doors, unlike the entrances determined by the lower court, to change the number of the victims or the damaged persons away from the Defendant; (b) in full view, the Defendant could sufficiently be recognized as having inflicted injury on the victim, as shown in the facts charged in the instant case.

2. The following circumstances acknowledged by the lower court based on the evidence duly admitted and investigated by the lower court, namely, ① the Defendant consistently asserted that the right side of the entrance from the investigative agency to the court is the front door, and the photograph (the 19th page of the investigation record) and the statement on the repair of the entrance (the 8th page of the investigation record) have been submitted to the Defendant, in view of the following circumstances acknowledged by the lower court based on these evidence. In so doing, there was a dispute at other entrances.

보기는 어려운 점, ② 피고인은 피고 인의 양복점 내에서 피해자와 술을 마시다가 다툼이 일어나자 피해 자를 양복점 밖으로 내보내려고 하였고, 피해자는 밖으로 나가지 않으려고 버텼으며, 피해자는 양복점 밖으로 내보 내진 후 피고인과 출입문을 사이에 두고 출입문을 밀고 당기며 다투었던 사실을 인정할 수 있는데, 피고인이 피해자를 자신의 양복점에서 내보내려 하거나 내보낸 후 다시 들어오려는 피해자를 막는 과정에서 피해자에게 문에 끼이는 상해가 발생하였다면, 그 과정에서 과실로 피해자에게 상해를 입게 한 것은 별론으로 하고, 상해에 대하여 피고인이 범의를 가지고 있었다고

It is difficult to see. ③ The defendant demanded the victim in dispute between the victim and the victim to leave the two uniforms of the defendant, and the victim who refuses it.