beta
(영문) 수원지방법원 평택지원 2019.05.03 2018고정234

상해

Text

Defendant

A shall be punished by a fine of one million won, by a fine of three hundred thousand won, and by a fine of two hundred thousand won.

Reasons

Punishment of the crime

1. On September 20, 2017, Defendants B and C jointly committed a common crime at the cafeterias of “E” located in Pyeongtaek-si in Gyeonggi-si on September 13:40, 2017, Defendant B, on the ground that Defendant B, who was the mother of the injured party A (V, 27 years of age), was to be exempted from the restaurant, and Defendant B, on the ground that the injured party took the bath, and Defendant B, by hand, she was tightly pushed the injured party’s shoulder and knife his head, and Defendant C assaulted the injured party, who was able to take the part of the injured party’s hand with his hand.

2. Defendant A, as described in paragraph (1) at the time, at the place, as described in paragraph (1), the victim B (n, 54 years of age) and paragraph (1), had the victim’s head debt knife, knife the victim B’s head debt knife, knife the victim’s knife, knife the victim’s knife, knife the victim’s knife, knife the victim’s knife, knife the victim’s knife, and knife the victim’s knife, knife the victim’s knife, and knife the victim C’s kn

Summary of Evidence

【One point in the market】

1. A’s legal statement;

1. Part of the Defendant B’s written statement

1. Partial statement of the police statement on Defendant B (including the G statement part)

1. Some statements in the police interrogation protocol regarding Defendant B

1. Photographs photographs of the victim of the suspect's assault;

1. In full view of the above evidence, it is reasonable to view that the defendant committed an assault against the victim A, considering the following facts: (a) internal investigation report (the defendant B alleged that the victim did not assault the victim A; (b) the investigative agency stated that the victim was satisfed by a defect in the victim’s desire; and (c) the above evidence. Therefore, the defendant C does not accept the defendant’s assertion. Although the defendant merely committed an unilateral assault against the victim A, the victim and the victim’s mother (F) did not commit an assault against the victim.