A and C shall be punished by a fine of 700,000 won, and Defendant B shall be punished by a fine of 300,000 won.

The above fine is imposed against the Defendants.

1. Defendant C and Defendant A’s violation of the Personal Information Protection Act is an operator of the following website, who manages and operates personal information files, such as the name, address, contact information, etc. of the above car page members when entering the car page. Defendant A is a general member of the above car page.

A personal information manager shall not provide a third party with personal information without the consent of the subject of information, and no person shall be provided with personal information with the knowledge of such circumstances.

Defendant

A, as a member of the above carpet, discovered the fact that G, using the F 'F 'F', has posted a critical comments on Defendant A's car page, and had the mind to resist G.

Defendant

A, on February 2, 2014, Goyang-gu H and Dong 404, contacted the Defendant C, who is a carpet operator, at his own residence, with the F'F's cell phone number known to him.

Defendant

C received the above contact from Defendant A at the J Abandonment Protection Office located in Scheon-si I on the same day, and contacted Defendant A, and confirmed the mobile phone number (M) and notified Defendant A of the F's cell phone number by accessing the F Kack Eck, Ec, Ec, Ec, Ec, and by informing A of the F Kack's mobile phone number. On the same day, K had access to the above Kack by using Defendant C's clinic and password, which was known in accordance with Defendant C's instructions at the Hackh Institute located in Yangcheon-gu, Seoul on the same day, at the Hack's educational institute located in Yangcheon-gu, Seoul, by using Defendant C's clinic and password.

As a result, Defendant C, a personal information manager, provides Defendant A with the mobile phone numbers of G, which are personal information, without obtaining the consent of G, which is a personal information subject, and Defendant A is personal information even with knowledge of such circumstances.