1. The plaintiff's appeal against the defendant call corporation is dismissed.

2. Any claim added by this Court.

1. Basic facts

A. The Plaintiff’s patented invention is a patentee with respect to the following patented inventions (hereinafter “instant patented inventions” and “instant Claim No. 1” respectively.

1) Name: Dice 2) / Date of priority claim / Date of application / Registration / Registration : May 10, 2007 / May 9, 2008 / 103188) claims and major drawings: as shown in attached Form 2. (b) Defendant Korea Call-gu Co., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant Call-gu”) (hereinafter “Defendant”) produced at the request of the U.S. Law School (hereinafter “S. Law School”) in accordance with the request of the Defendant Jinma Co., Ltd., Ltd. (hereinafter “Defendant Jin-gu”), the scope of claims and major drawings: attached Form 2.

A. A. The products indicated in the port description and markings (hereinafter “Class 1 products”) contain cosmetics manufactured by Defendant Call, and supplied them to the Port Posium, and the Port Posium was sold to consumers under the name “Macroly Eye Act 100”.

2. The defendant Syune No. 2 of the list of infringed products in attached Form 1

B. List 2- same as the products described in the port and marked (hereinafter “Class 2 products”)

다. 항 기재 및 표기 제품(이하 ‘제3 제품’이라 한다. 제1, 2, 3 제품을 합하여 ‘이 사건 피고 제품들’이라 한다)을 각 생산하고 있고, 제2 제품은 ‘게리쏭(Guerisson Multi Corrective Eye Cream)’이라는 이름으로, 제3 제품은 ‘허니세라(HONEY cera)’라는 이름으로 소비자들에게 판매되고 있다.

C. Cited Invention 1, 2, 7, and 11, as a utility model, constitutes “a device” but actually constitutes “an invention” in comparison with the instant patent invention.

1) Cited Invention 1 (Evidence B or 7) published on December 11, 2006 in Korea’s Utility Model Gazette 43606.